Put a Pin on the Map View my Forum Guestmap
Free Guestmaps by Bravenet.com

The Old Acclaimed Music Forum

Go to the NEW FORUM

Music, music, music...
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
Mega-Critic-Competition : Win A CD : The Clues

There are only two more days left (deadline = 25th) to guess the highest new entry into the Mega-Critic-Chart (publication = 30th) and to enter the chance to win that CD.

So far the following guesses are noted :

Mitchell Stirling : Portishead
Sketch and Penguin : Sun Kil Moon
BillAdama : Frightened Rabbit
John : Flight Of The Conchords

Didn´t get noted, as they figured already in last month`s chart :

brennen : Elbow (# 26)
Stephan : Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds (# 2)

The following five acts seem to become the highest new entries this month :

Clue to act 1 : a male duo from ohio
Clue to act 2 : a female twin duo from ohio
Clue to act 3 : a male duo from bristol
Clue to act 4 : a trio from bristol
Clue to act 5 : a (now) solo artist from brisbane/australia

Good luck !

Re: Mega-Critic-Competition : Win A CD : The Clues

Hmm ok, I thought it was released this month. Well, I'll go for the safe choice then and pick Portishead. It's not quite as good as Dummy, but I think it'll be received well.

Re: Mega-Critic-Competition : Win A CD : The Clues

I'll go with The Black Keys - Attack & Release

Re: Mega-Critic-Competition : Win A CD : The Clues

Street Horrrsing from the Fuck Buttons?

Pitchfork praises it, but personally I'm not sure if I would want to win that CD

Re: Mega-Critic-Competition : Win A CD : The Clues

oops my bad...I'll take a stab at The Breeders - Mountain Battles

Re: Mega-Critic-Competition : Win A CD : The Clues

Elbow

Re: Mega-Critic-Competition : Win A CD : The Clues

Can I change my answer?

Re: Mega-Critic-Competition : Win A CD : The Clues

The Fuck Buttons CD is pretty good but it has a bit of a catch 22. It requires an attention span to 'get', but the payoff isn't quite good enough for most people to justify the span.

It's one of those CDs that doesn't quite fit into a genre but it's close to a few, so people not a fan of the genre won't accept it for being too close to the genre, and people who are fans of the genre won't accept it for not being close enough.

I've heard terms thrown around like 'Drone for people who don't like drone' and other various knee-jerk pigeonholings. Really it's not nearly as good or bad as anyone says.

Re: Mega-Critic-Competition : Win A CD : The Clues

Yes John, up to the 25th you can change your vote...

Re: Mega-Critic-Competition : Win A CD : The Clues

OK, I'm going with Jim Noir.

Re: Mega-Critic-Competition : Win A CD : The Clues

I don't think he fits the criteria, but I didn't even know he had a new album coming out and it popped up to great reviews so I'm going with the wild card.

Re: Mega-Critic-Competition : Win A CD : The Clues

Hope I'm not too late but I'll go for Robert Forster - The Evangelist