Put a Pin on the Map View my Forum Guestmap
Free Guestmaps by Bravenet.com

The Old Acclaimed Music Forum

Go to the NEW FORUM

Music, music, music...
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
View Entire Thread
Re: MEGA-CRITIC-COMPETITION OCTOBER : THE CLUES

Stefan allows you to change your vote.

Re: MEGA-CRITIC-COMPETITION OCTOBER : THE CLUES

I will go with Lindstrom at #47

Re: MEGA-CRITIC-COMPETITION OCTOBER : THE CLUES

I'm thinking Deerhoof at 19. Pretty weak month...

Re: MEGA-CRITIC-COMPETITION OCTOBER : THE CLUES

Question, Stefan: Are you planning to list the Bob Dylan album on Mega-Critic? Technically, it's probably eligible, consisting as it does of previously unreleased material. Just wondering. (I suppose that eventually, this will become a question for Henrik as well.)

Re: MEGA-CRITIC-COMPETITION OCTOBER : THE CLUES

^ I was also wondering about the new Dylan as well. Glad you brought it up.

It sure is getting much praise.

Re: MEGA-CRITIC-COMPETITION OCTOBER : THE CLUES

Well, my vote for Oasis was right at the beginning of the month, without even having heard it. And now that I did hear it, it's clear that it's a nice album for Oasis fans, but not that great or sparkling new ...

So, if possible, I would like to withdraw that vote.

From the five acts listed above I only know Lindstrom and I even like it. Not gonna vote for it though, may John win that CD.

No, I'm gonna vote for The Week That Was at #41, naively hoping this will all happen in the last 10 days of the month ...

Re: MEGA-CRITIC-COMPETITION OCTOBER : THE CLUES

The Week that Was at #23 !

Re: MEGA-CRITIC-COMPETITION OCTOBER : THE CLUES

Deerhoof at #21

Re: MEGA-CRITIC-COMPETITION OCTOBER : THE CLUES

If Dylan is eligable I change my vote to that at #15.

Because it's the one I don't have yet.

Re: MEGA-CRITIC-COMPETITION OCTOBER : THE CLUES

Oh man... Deerhunter's Microcastle is getting awesome reviews! Not sure if it's even eligible for the next update since it just came out yesterday, but if it is, I truly regret not picking it.

Re: MEGA-CRITIC-COMPETITION OCTOBER : THE CLUES

Deerhunter at #11

Re: MEGA-CRITIC-COMPETITION OCTOBER : THE CLUES

Deerhunter's already #9 in my comparison based rating, and that's with a limited number of reviews.

Of course, Lindstrom's #13. So you never know.

Re: MEGA-CRITIC-COMPETITION OCTOBER : THE CLUES

I'm sure Deerhunter isn't eligible... right..? I mean, the official CD release was after the deadline to submit a vote here.

Oh well, I love Microcastle. If there's one album I wouldn't mind losing to, it's that one.

Re: MEGA-CRITIC-COMPETITION OCTOBER : THE CLUES

That wasn't a vote, it was a comment.

My original vote stands, unless the Bob Dylan is eligable in which case my vote changed to that a few days ago.