2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
We've reached the half-way point of the list, and what a list it's been! The lower 100 have seen many overlooked gems vying with revered classics, and the results have been very fun to post. Catch up with Part 2 if you like.
Here's the story so far:
200 . Franz Ferdinand - Take Me Out
199 . Kylie Minogue - Can’t Get You Out of My Head
198 . Grandmaster Flash & The Furious Five - The Message
197 . Curtis Mayfield - Move on Up
196 . Police, The - Every Breath You Take
195 . Björk - Isobel
194 . Smashing Pumpkins, The - Today
193 . Beatles, The - And Your Bird Can Sing
192 . Clash, The - Spanish Bombs
191 . Björk - Bachelorette
190 . Miles Davis - So What
189 . Doors, The - The End
188 . Thunderclap Newman - Something in the Air
187 . Bruce Springsteen - Jungleland
186 . Deee-Lite - Groove Is in the Heart
185 . Flaming Lips, The - Race for the Prize
184 . Human League - Don't You Want Me
183 . Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Maps
182 . Jam, The - Going Underground
181 . New Order - Ceremony
180 . Beatles, The - Revolution
179 . Joy Division - Disorder
178 . Byrds, The - Eight Miles High
177 . Band, The - The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down
176 . Johnny Cash - Hurt
175 . Beatles, The - Happiness is a Warm Gun
174 . Coldplay - Yellow
173 . Leonard Cohen - Famous Blue Raincoat
172 . R.E.M. - Drive
171 . Mamas and the Papas - California Dreamin'
170 . Blur - This Is A Low
169 . Prince - Sign o' The Times
168 . Who, The - My Generation
167 . Kinks, The - You Really Got Me
166 . Prince - Kiss
165 . Replacements, The - Unsatisfied
164 . Bob Marley and the Wailers - No Woman No Cry
163 . Smiths, The - Bigmouth Strikes Again
162 . Notorious B.I.G. - Juicy
161 . Prince - Little Red Corvette
160 . Smashing Pumpkins, The - Tonight, Tonight
159 . Flaming Lips, The - Do You Realize?
158 . Blur - Song 2
157 . Mercury Rev - Godess On A Hi-Way
156 . David Bowie - Space Oddity
155 . Pixies - Gigantic
154 . Simon and Garfunkel - America
153 . Sufjan Stevens - John Wayne Gacy, Jr.
152 . Del Shannon - Runaway
151 . R.E.M. - It's the End of the World As We Know It (And I Feel Fine)
150 . Stone Roses, The - I Am the Resurrection
149 . Otis Redding - Try a Little Tenderness
148 . Neil Young - Cortez the Killer
147 . New Radicals - You Get What You Give
146 . Knife, The - Heartbeats
145 . R.E.M. - World Leader Pretend
144 . Breeders, The - Cannonball
143 . Zombies, The - Hung Up on a Dream
142 . White Stripes, The - Fell in Love with a Girl
141 . Radiohead - Pyramid Song
140 . David Bowie - Station to Station
139 . Beck - Loser
138 . New Order - Bizarre Love Triangle (Extended)
137 . Prince - Let's Go Crazy
136 . Iggy Pop - The Passenger
135 . New Order - Temptation
134 . Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here
133 . Jimi Hendrix - Purple Haze
132 . David Bowie - Ashes to Ashes
131 . Pixies - Where Is My Mind?
130 . Arcade Fire, The - Wake Up
129 . James Brown - Get Up (I Feel Like Being a) Sex Machine
128 . Radiohead - Idioteque
127 . Gnarls Barkley - Crazy
126 . Lou Reed - Perfect Day
125 . Ike & Tina Turner - River Deep, Mountain High
124 . Specials, The - Ghost Town
123 . R.E.M. - Radio Free Europe
122 . Animals, The - House of the Rising Sun
121 . Eurythmics - Sweet Dreams (Are Made Of This)
120 . Stan Getz with Joao and Astrud Gilberto - The Girl From Ipanema
119 . Portishead - Glory Box
118 . Arcade Fire, The - Rebellion (Lies)
117 . Strokes, The - Last Nite
116 . Pixies - Monkey Gone to Heaven
115 . Creedence Clearwater Revival - Fortunate Son
114 . Beastie Boys - Sabotage
113 . Al Green - Let's Stay Together
112 . Ben E. King - Stand By Me
111 . Beatles, The - Blackbird
110 . Beatles, The - Yesterday
109 . Guns N' Roses - Sweet Child O' Mine
108 . Wilco - Jesus, Etc.
107 . OutKast - B.O.B. (bombs over baghdad)
106 . Talking Heads - Psycho Killer
105 . U2 - With Or without You
104 . Pulp - This Is Hardcore
103 . Louis Armstrong - What a Wonderful World
102 . Echo and the Bunnymen - The Killing Moon
101 . Jeff Buckley - Last Goodbye
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
99. Massive Attack- Unfinished Sympathy (1991)
Total points: 215.98
Place in the 2005 poll: 166
Appears on: 10 ballots
Ranked by:
Vgrd (1
Honorio (41)
Rendle (51)
Henrik (85)
Mitchell Stirling (104)
Andre (121)
Greg (143)
Pop Elton (153)
Lonesome Panda (190)
Ajackson (193)
Comments:
Honorio: Culling elements from diverse styles, Massive Attack designed the everlasting electronic hymn of the 90s, equally apt for dancing madly on the dance floor (courtesy of its house rhythm and hip-hop scratching) and for listening quietly in your bedroom (courtesy of its amazing string arrangements and the soulful Shara Nelson vocals).
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
Yes, we're counting down again!
The River is a surprise at #96 (the overall position, not Nicolas' vote). It's undervalued at AM due to its late release as a single (sometime in 1981, I think).
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
Hey I'm at my home computer so I can listen while I wait! I would never have imagined that I would end up being the biggest fans of Yeah Yeah Yeahs' Maps or SP's 1979.
Thanks for bringing up Beach Boys' later albums in the threads over the pass year. That is what sparked my interest in Surf's Up and what hopefully assisted Till I Die's strong showing!
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
87. The Velvet Underground & Nico- Heroin (1967)
Total points: 229.57
Place in the 2005 poll: 76
Appears on: 11 ballots
Ranked by:
Ozphoenix (35)
Pop Elton (39)
Neoptolemos (74)
Stammer (7
Rune (86)
Giuseppe (8
Moonbeam (94)
BillAdama (100.5)
Midaso (112)
Slush (176)
Mo (184)
Comments:
Moonbeam: The entire song sounds like a raw, bleeding, extracted heart, complete with the slightly jagged strings and the rapidly changing percussion. It’s rare that pain is expressed in such an honest, true way.
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
Great !
2 satisfactions
- The River. My number 2, my favorite rock song.
- Gainsbourg : even if it is not my favorite song by him (I prefer "Je suis venu te dire que je m'en vais"). GReat to see a French song so hugh ! So Honorio you were right!
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
Looking back, I didn't review "Heroin" very well! What I meant to say is that I think it's brilliant how the song's raw strings and rapidly changing percussion mimic a burnt heart's reaction to heroin.
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
Bye
I'm falling from exhaustion
Just passing by
I'll read that tomorrow morning
Thanks Moonbeam and congratulations for posting these results And packing your moving boxes
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
Oh man, Echoes. Best opening second ever? 'Everything In Its Right Place' might just take that prize for me though. How great that we're back under way!
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
This list continues to amaze me! Who would have thought that "How to Disappear Completely" would make the top 100. I didn't vote for it, but I think it's fantastic.
And congrats to Schleuse and Stammer. Great track! I wonder if you have similar taste in general?
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
how to disappear completely!? u serious!? a good song, a very good song, but IMO, it doesn't even deserve to be on the list, let alone in the top 100. having said that, if there's anyone who doesn't have the right to complain about the results, it's me. i chose not to influence them... by the way, thanks heaps moonbeam, i didn't know quite a few of these songs and i probably wouldn't still if it wasn't for your posting youtube links. they're all fantastic songs so i'm glad you've made it convenient for me to listen to them. big thanks everyone who participated, and to moonbeam in particular. thanks for expanding my musical knowledge
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
Pity - I slept through this (that flu that Anthony had for the albums poll seems to have made it to Europe in the meantime), but it'll be fun to catch up on. Grand presentation, Moonbeam!
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
Yes I agree Moeboid,to have How To Disappear Completely at #81 is completely unexpected - not a song I'd put among their best. I'll have to get 'Fall On Me' - I have 5 R.E.M. albums but have never heard that particular song...
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
I'm with you Schlesue. While my top list is always changing "Fall On Me" has been on top since 1986.
Your comment about seeing it performed live got me thinking, does anybody have songs that they don't particularly like the studio version but live performances, covers, alt. takes, etc. make them reevaluate and put the song on their list. Alternately any songs that you think "man that could be a great song" but just couldn't put it on your list because of bad production, etc.
Wichita Lineman by Glen Campbell was one for me. I always liked the song but for years couldn't get by the cheesy 70's production, particularly the intro. But hearing many covers (including REM) and especially some of Glen's own bareboned live versions (there's a great in studio version with Stone Temple Pilots of all people) the song has steadily moved up to near the top of my list.
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
I got one. When I first heard Vanessa Carlton's "Ordinary Day" I thought it was rather boring, but one day a friend of mine sent me an acoustic live version of the song and it blew me away. It's at #151 in my list right now.
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
I'm being totally detailed-obsessed hear but I thought I had the highest ranking for SP's 1979 when I made an earlier comment, when in fact I overlooked the boldface that said Pop Elton had made it his #1. Good tastes, P.E., and thanks for giving the songs the hefty points to get it into the top 100.
So for now it looks like I was the biggest champion of Maps. Fine with me.
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
I haven't weighed in on the song list yet, probably mostly because I didn't participate and thus have no real "rooting interest" - it's just fun to watch it unfold. Now that we're well into the top 100, though, I feel compelled to echo the consensus that this is one hell of a fascinating, eclectic list, with more genuine surprises than one normally finds on top-songs lists.
That said, I fully expect to see more and more dominance by a few selected artists (BD, the B's, Rh, maybe the RS) as we get closer to the top. I could be wrong, but I tend to doubt it.
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
I agree with you guys. I'm just a slow learner I have over 50 cover versions of the song and the original is by far the definitive one. Just for me it took the song to be reduced to the haunting melody and Glen's beautiful voice to appreciate what a "great" song it was.
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
Stammer : to answer your question, I think Thirteen would not be in my top 10 without Elliott Smith's cover ! But well, I like the original one and it would have been in my top 200 in any case, but I love that cover so much !
And I probably would not know Sly Stone's Loose Booty if Beastie Boys has not used almost every bit of that song to make Shadrach.
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
Since I put it in #6, I think only one more vote would have been enough to make Thirteen reach the top 500... since we haven't seen it yet, it must be in the top 75 !
(you can guess the name about your top 3 songs if they have not appeared yet in the top 500 ! )
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
Yeah Smokey is the man ! I've put some Smokey in my list but with another song ("ooo baby baby"). "The tracks of my tears" is a pure motown classic too !
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
72. Eminem featuring Dido- Stan (2000)
Total points: 262.86
Place in the 2005 poll: 70
Appears on: 7 ballots
Ranked by:
Ajackson (10)
Mo (1
Honorio (34)
Henrik (44)
Greg (69)
Midaso (75)
Rendle (84)
Comments:
Honorio: It’s my favourite song from the 00s, and the eight years passed by hadn’t dethroned it yet. Probably the best example of storytelling in music, it’s more a novel or a movie than a song. And the story cleverly told as fan mail and the perfectly build dramatic crescendo was astonishingly brilliant. It puts a lump in my throat. Amazing.
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
Of course I'm delighted Wyatt made it to the albums AND song polls
Mark Propp I don't know you but in case you're listening
you've got great taste (Rock Bottom was my nb 2 album)
and bravo to all the others that helped Sae song make it
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
Neat! I thought Roy Orbison was out of the picture when I saw Pretty Woman below the top 200. It was hard to pick something from him to put on my list. He has a lot of great, but not timeless songs, and Pretty Woman inched in at my #100. In Dreams was a close call for me.
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
And now the big "O" ! Amazing song. I'm very glad to see some Roy Orbison. This poll is very great. AMers, let me say to you that you all have a great taste in music !
Moonbeam: I owe more to this song than any other, and my introduction to it and experience with it have shaped my musical journey every step of the way. It acts as the thesis statement of what I deem the greatest album ever recorded, and its fusion of synthesized funk, chicken-scratching guitar, hungry underdog attitude and thinly veiled spiritual message defines what makes Prince so great to me. The duel of good vs. evil and spiritual vs. carnal is embodied by not only the lyrics, but the instrumentation, as the infectious synth line captures the inherent ecstasy of the rapture while the ominously innovative and propulsive drum machine loop carries the foreboding sense of doom. A true song for the ages, its legacy lives well beyond the expiration of its calendar relevance.
Again, no Youtube vid, but click on the image below to hear this wicked song.
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
Unless you really want to try to do it well, I don’t think Orbison is the ideal karoeke artist. I know my limits and his high octave warbles are nearly impossible for anyone to sing. A drunken, unserious attempt at singing him wouldn’t be amusing to hear or watch.
Re: 2008 Acclaimed Music Songs Poll: The Results (Part 3)
It was pretty awful. Luckily, the bar was pretty packed and the people I was with said they couldn't hear me and I had an Arnold Schwartzanegger mask on and a suit. I should have just lip-synced it like in Blue Velvet although that's probably even more disturbing.