Put a Pin on the Map View my Forum Guestmap
Free Guestmaps by Bravenet.com

The Old Acclaimed Music Forum

Go to the NEW FORUM

Music, music, music...
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
UMT 3.14...

#1 Prince vs. #4 Wilson Pickett
#3 Earth, Wind & Fire vs. #6 Daft Punk vs. #2 Iron Maiden
#1 Foo Fighters vs. #5 Sex Pistols
#6 Carl Perkins vs. #2 Elvis Costello
#1 Queen vs. #4 Run DMC
#3 Huey Lewis & The News vs. #2 John Lennon
#8 Vampire Weekend vs. #5 Bjork
#11 The Prodigy vs. #2 Santana

Re: UMT 3.14...

Slicks Votes... PRINCE... MAIDEN... FOO... ELVIS COSTELLO... QUEEN (that one hurt)... HUEY LEWIS & THE NEWS... VAMPIRE WEEKEND... THE PRODIGY...

Slicks Predictions...
PRINCE -- Tough draw for Mr. Pickett
TOSS UP -- Classic 3-way battle between all great bands but conflicting styles. My guess 2 or 3 votes seperate 1st from 3rd...
TOSS UP -- An above average rock band that has put out good albums for 15 years vs. 1 great album...
ELVIS -- Before the tourney if you had a bet on which Elvis would go further...
TOSS UP -- Wow, talk about a matchup where 1/3 of the voters are strong one way, 1/3 another and the remainder are like me having extreme difficulty choosing a winner...
LENNON -- I would imagine Huey's run coming to an end...
TOSS UP -- Slight edge to Bjork, but quite a few votes will go strictly against her as well...
SANTANA -- Can Prodigy make this close????

Re: UMT 3.14...

Prince
EWF
Pistols
Costello
Queen
Huey (I still hate Imagine)
Bjork
Santana

Fave: Queen
FNVF: Run DMC
Fave Song: Bohemian Rhapsody
Fave Album: Purple Rain

Re: UMT 3.14...

Prince
Daft Punk
Sex Pistols
Elvis Costello
Run-D.M.C.
John Lennon
Björk
The Prodigy (not a huge fan of either artist here)

Wilson Pickett, Carl Perkins, Run-D.M.C. and Vampire Weekend all drew very rough matchups…VW could upset Björk, but I’m doubting it.

Re: UMT 3.14...

Prince
Daft Punk
Sex Pistols
Elvis Costello
Run-D.M.C.
John Lennon
Björk
Santana

I have to say, there wasn't a single difficult decision for me here. I enjoy all these artists regularly, bar Santana. That said, if I'm with friends, I would much rather them put Santana on than Prodigy. The three-ways are alwasy so interesting, but I feel pretty comfortable with Daft Punk.

Re: UMT 3.14...

#1 Prince
#6 Daft Punk
#5 Sex Pistols
#2 Elvis Costello
#1 Queen
#2 John Lennon
#5 Bjork
#2 Santana

Re: UMT 3.14...

#1 Prince
#6 Daft Punk
#5 Sex Pistols
#2 Elvis Costello
#4 Run DMC
#2 John Lennon
#5 Bjork
#2 Santana

"Huey Lewis and the News will form a Huey Lewis and the News tribute band, just to prove that someone might actually want to do that."
-- From a Conan O'Brien "In the Year 3000" segment, delivered by Mr. T

Re: UMT 3.14...

Prince
Daft Punk
Sex Pistols (though I do like the Foo Fighters)
Elvis Costello
Queen
John Lennon (your time has come Huey!)
Vampire Weekend (While I like Bjork, I've never really gotten that into her)
Santana

Re: UMT 3.14...

#1 Prince
#6 Daft Punk
#1 Foo Fighters
As influential a band as they are, I can't stand the Sex Pistols.
#2 Elvis Costello
#4 Run DMC
Queen sucks. But they'll win.
#2 John Lennon
Lennon actually has a chance to beat Queen. And Huey Lewis & The News suck.
#5 Bjork
Vampire Weekend is good but overrated.
#2 Santana
Can't stand The Prodigy.

Re: UMT 3.14...

#1 Prince: Surprise, surprise!
#3 Earth, Wind & Fire: Tough choice between them and Daft Punk for me! Iron Maiden intrigues me, but I haven't given them a shot yet. That said, I tend to side with funk.
#5 Sex Pistols: I'm not a huge fan or anything, but I like their album. Foo Fighters are ok, but none of their singles have really leapt out at me.
#2 Elvis Costello: This Year's Model was a total blitzkrieg for me last year!
#4 Run-D.M.C.: Essential, fun early hip hop or limp glam-lite? Easy choice.
#3 Huey Lewis & the News: I'll probably be the only one voting this way, but I'd be much happier to be stuck with them than John Lennon- geesh.
#5 Björk: One of the very few artists that ever challenge Prince for supremacy for me.
#11 The Prodigy: I'm not a huge fan of either, but I quite like "Breathe".

Favorite artist: Prince (#1 all-time), closely followed by Björk (in a 5-way tie for #2)
Favorite artist I didn't vote for: Daft Punk
Favorite album: 1999 (#1 all-time)
Favorite song: "Something in the Water (Does Not Compute)" (#1 all-time)

Re: UMT 3.14...

#1 Prince
#6 Daft Punk
#1 Foo Fighters - there's no band who only released one album that I'd pick over a band like the Foo Fighters...
#2 Elvis Costello
#1 Queen
#2 John Lennon
#5 Bjork
#2 Santana

Re: UMT 3.14...

#1 Prince
#6 Daft Punk
#5 Sex Pistols
#2 Elvis Costello
#1 Queen
#3 Huey Lewis & The News (I'm with you Moonbeam, although Huey would have lost against most of the losers in other brackets as well)
#5 Bjork
#2 Santana

Re: UMT 3.14...

#1 Prince
#3 Earth, Wind & Fire
#1 Foo Fighters
#2 Elvis Costello
#1 Queen
#2 John Lennon
#8 Vampire Weekend
#2 Santana

Re: UMT 3.14...

Prince
Daft Punk
Foo Fighters
Elvis Costello
Queen
John Lennon
Bjork

Re: UMT 3.14...

Prince
Iron Maiden
Sex Pistols
Elvis Costello
Queen
John Lennon
Bjork
The Prodigy

Re: UMT 3.14...

Prince
Daft Punk
Foo Fighters (it appears that I have forgotten The Colour and the Shape in my favourite albums history)
Elvis Costello
Queen (tougher call in a while, despite Rock Box and It's Tricky, I would say Queen is a better band in terms of singles, while Run DMC have probably much less crap in their discography. But like for the FF, points for nostalgia this morning.)
pass
Bjork
Prodigy

Re: UMT 3.14...

#1 Prince
#6 Daft Punk
#1 Foo Fighters
#2 Elvis Costello
#1 Queen
#2 John Lennon
#8 Vampire Weekend
#2 Santana

Re: UMT 3.14...

Prince - Not a big Pickett fan.
Daft Punk - Frankly, I don't know who I would choose between Daft Punk and Prince should they make it through next round. I think it would be foolish not to pick Prince, but I really enjoy Daft Punk.
Sex Pistols - Close call. I enjoy the Foo Fighters and think highly of their straight ahead rock.
Elvis Costello
Queen - I'm feeling these days like Run DMC may be overrated. They certainly never gave us anything as fun and fine as A Night at the Opera.
John Lennon
Bjork - Like VW, but they are not in the same league.
The Prodigy - But both are weak third rounders.

Favorite this round - Bjork
Favorite not voted for - Vampire Weekend

Re: UMT 3.14...

Prince
Daft Punk
Sex Pistols
Elvis Costello
Queen
Huey Lewis
Bjork
Santana

Re: UMT 3.14...

Prince
Daft Punk
Foo Fighters
Elvis Costello
Queen
John Lennon
Bjork
Santana

Re: UMT 3.14...

winners in 3.14...
Prince 97.1% / Wilson Pickett 2.9%
Daft Punk 48.6% / Iron Maiden 28.5% / Earth Wind & Fire 22.9%
Foo Fighters 51.4% / Sex Pistols 48.6%
Elvis Costello 88.6% / Carl Perkins 11.4%
Queen 66.7% / Run DMC 33.3%
John Lennon 63.6% / Huey Lewis & The News 36.4%
Bjork 66.7% / Vampire Weekend 33.3%
Santana 70.6% / The Prodigy 29.4%

Re: UMT 3.14...

Slick

Foo Fighters 51.4% / Sex Pistols 48.6%


Wow. I hate the Pistols, but I thought that matchup was a gimme for them. What was the AM/non-AM split?

Re: UMT 3.14...

BillAdama
Slick

Foo Fighters 51.4% / Sex Pistols 48.6%


Wow. I hate the Pistols, but I thought that matchup was a gimme for them. What was the AM/non-AM split?



AM = 11-8 Sex Pistols
Non-AM = 10-6 Foo
Surprisingly pretty even...