So far, unless I recognized a source from a previous year, I haven't included it.

I started checking Alexa for new sources and it seems like

Eligible: Gorilla vs. Bear, American Songwriter
Ineligible: Mowno

Those are the only ones I've checked so far.

Why Mowno would be ineligible ?

Henrik, does a website have to meet one or both of the requirements?

Mowno doesn't have enough sites linking in. It's traffic rank in comparable to AM.

Mowno looks OK to me, with 249 sites linking in (>100).

Wow, Gorilla vs Bear is huge now! If my memory serves it was deemed ineligible last year because of poor stats... Harold, do you read this?

Edit: The Alexa stats has been good for a long time, but they are only two writers and have therefore been excluded in the past. Hmm...

Hello,
I just found a French rock site with all requirements OK.

Albumrock.net

http://www.albumrock.net/critiquesalbums/les-critiques-albums.html

All the EOY since 2006 and a big EOD is available.
Do you want the lists ?

Dummy seems to have good enough Alexa stats to make it eligible.

Also, I'd like to thank everyone who has been posting lists. This wouldn't be possible without all of you.

Definitely!