Put a Pin on the Map View my Forum Guestmap
Free Guestmaps by Bravenet.com

The Old Acclaimed Music Forum

Go to the NEW FORUM

Critics' lists
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
View Entire Thread
Re: I Believe That...

Shit...

Re: I Believe That...

JR
Henrik said that any new artist-based lists should be 50 or more tracks.
Well, that's what I said when you bombarded me with top 10 Madonna lists , but I don't think that this rule is written in stone. A top 30 list with a comment for each entry is fine with me.

Re: I Believe That...

Henrik
JR
Henrik said that any new artist-based lists should be 50 or more tracks.
Well, that's what I said when you bombarded me with top 10 Madonna lists , but I don't think that this rule is written in stone. A top 30 list with a comment for each entry is fine with me.


I could kiss you in a completely heterosexual/platonic way.

Hey Hey Now...

One list was a top 10, but had 20-something "Honorable Mentions."

Re: Hey Hey Now...

So Henrik, does the list help push anymore Wilco songs into the top 3000? I know "Poor Places", "Via Chicago" and "A Shot in the Arm" have gotten love on some soon to be included lists.

There Are A Number...

of lists to be added, so I don't know if Henrik can guesstimate that. Plus, since artist lists only get measured against that act's tracks, I'm not sure how much of an impact these kinds of lists have.

Re: There Are A Number...

So basically the only songs it will help are the ones ranked above "Jesus, Etc" which is set to have a pretty big leap next update due to decade end lists.

Re: There Are A Number...

Jonathon
So basically the only songs it will help are the ones ranked above "Jesus, Etc" which is set to have a pretty big leap next update due to decade end lists.
Yes, that seems to be the way it is. And the only song that's nestled in between "I Am Trying to Break Your Heart" and "Jesus Etc." is "Misunderstood" which I think has not appeared in any lists before, so probably no new songs will be added due to this list...