http://gorillavsbear.blogspot.com/2009/08/albums-of-decade-2000-2009.html

This one indeed seems eligible. And they have EOD songs and EOY albums & songs lists too. If someone wants to posts these lists here in the forum that would be great.

gorilla vs. bear's favorite albums of the decade | 2000-2009

01 panda bear | person pitch (2007)
02 the strokes | is this it (2001)
03 ghostface killah | supreme clientele (2000)
04 outkast | stankonia (2000)
05 radiohead | kid A (2000)
06 j dilla | donuts (2006)
07 sufjan stevens | michigan (2003)
08 burial | untrue (2007)
09 joanna newsom | the milk-eyed mender (2004)
10 m.i.a. + diplo | piracy funds terrorism vol. I (2004)
11 sigur ros | Ágætis Byrjun (2000*)
12 the arcade fire | funeral (2004)
13 white denim | fits (2009)
14 animal collective | feels (2005)
15 the streets | a grand don't come for free (2004)
16 grizzly bear | veckatimest (2009)
17 clipse | hell hath no fury (2006)
18 beach house | devotion (2008)
19 madvillain | madvillainy (2004)
20 the knife | silent shout (2006)

EOD - Albums:

01 panda bear | person pitch (2007)
02 the strokes | is this it (2001)
03 ghostface killah | supreme clientele (2000)
04 outkast | stankonia (2000)
05 radiohead | kid A (2000)
06 j dilla | donuts (2006)
07 sufjan stevens | michigan (2003)
08 burial | untrue (2007)
09 joanna newsom | the milk-eyed mender (2004)
10 m.i.a. + diplo | piracy funds terrorism vol. I (2004)
11 sigur ros | Ágætis Byrjun (2000*)
12 the arcade fire | funeral (2004)
13 white denim | fits (2009)
14 animal collective | feels (2005)
15 the streets | a grand don't come for free (2004)
16 grizzly bear | veckatimest (2009)
17 clipse | hell hath no fury (2006)
18 beach house | devotion (2008)
19 madvillain | madvillainy (2004)
20 the knife | silent shout (2006)

EOY 2009 - Albums:

25 pisces | a lovely sight
24 ganglians | monster head room
23 the mantles | the mantles
22 st. vincent | actor
21 cass mccombs | catacombs
20 atlas sound | logos
19 washed out | high times
18 night control | death control
17 phoenix | wolfgang amadeus phoenix
16 nirvana | live at reading
15 the mayfair set | young one
14 mountain man | mountain man
13 nite jewel | good evening
12 memory tapes | seek magic
11 neon indian | psychic chasms
10 fever ray | fever ray
09 jj | no. 2
08 girls | album
07 smith westerns | smith westerns
06 the sandwitches | how to make ambient sadcake
05 the xx | xx
04 animal collective | merriweather post pavilion
03 grizzly bear | veckatimest
02 white denim | fits
01 raekwon | only built 4 cuban linx pt. II

EOY 2009 - Songs:

01 Animal Collective | My Girls
02 Girls | Hellhole Ratrace
03 White Denim | Regina Holding Hands
04 Cass McCombs | You Saved My Life
05 Washed Out | Feel It All Around
06 Smith Westerns | Imagine Pt. 3 (demo)
07 Big Boi | Shine Blockas (feat. Gucci Mane)
08 Animal Collective | What Would I Want? Sky
09 Grizzly Bear | Ready, Able
10 Best Coast | When I'm With You
11 Major Lazer | Keep It Goin Louder
12 Phoenix | Lisztomania
13 Raekwon | 10 Bricks
14 The Bitters | Warrior
15 Family Portrait | Mega Secrets
16 The xx | You've Got the Love (Florence + the Machine cover)
17 jj | Ecstasy
18 Atlas Sound | Walkabout (feat. Noah Lennox)
19 Burial | Fostercare
20 Pearl Harbor | Luv Goon
21 Here We Go Magic | Fangela
22 The Sandwitches | Kiss Your Feet
23 Four Tet | Love Cry (Joy Orbison remix)
24 Dum Dum Girls | Rest of Our Lives (live)
25 Trailer Trash Tracys | Candy Girl
26 Memory Tapes | bicycle
27 The Mantles | Don't Lie
28 Fever Ray | Keep the Streets Empty for Me
29 Toro y Moi | Blessa
30 Taken by Trees | Anna
31 Memory Cassette | Asleep at a Party
32 VEGA | No Reasons
33 Burial + Four Tet | Moth
34 Pearl Harbor | Lost @ Sea
35 Bullion | Time for Us All to Love
36 Neon Indian | Mind, Drips
37 Real Estate | Beach Comber
38 Bat For Lashes | Daniel
39 The Mayfair Set | Already Warm
40 Woods | Death Rattles (Daytrotter session) / Rain On
41 Ganglians | Blood on the Sand
42 El Perro del Mar | Change of Heart
43 Forest Swords | Miarches
44 DOOM | That's That
45 Sharon Van Etten | For You
46 Wavves | No Hope Kids
47 Grouper | Hold the Way
48 SALEM | Frost
49 Vivian Girls | Tension
50 Tiny Vipers :: Development

They also have album and song lists for 2006, 2007 and 2008

EOY 2006 - Albums

13. J Dilla - Donuts
12. Cansei De Ser Sexy - CSS
11. Peter and the Wolf - Lightness
10. Hot Chip - The Warning
9. Grizzly Bear - Yellow House
8. Beach House - Beach House
7. Sunset Rubdown - Shut Up I Am Dreaming
6. Ghostface Killah - Fishscale
5. Love Is All - Nine Times That Same Song
4. Clipse - Hell Hath No Fury
3. Joanna Newsom - Ys
2. Midlake - The Trials of Van Occupanther
1. The Knife - Silent Shout

EOY 2006 - Songs

30. Oh No! Oh My! - Walk in the Park
29. Benoit Pioulard - Palimend
28. Voxtrot - Soft and Warm
27. Birdmonster - Spaceman
26. Sufjan Stevens - Sister Winter
25. Swan Lake - All Fires
24. The Blow - Parentheses
23. Ghostland Observatory - Piano Man
22. Alela Diane - Pieces of String
21. Clipse - New World feat. Pharrell
20. Ratatat - Wildcat mp3
19. Tacks, The Boy Disaster - Paris
18. Sound Team - TV Torso
17. CSS - Let's Make Love and Listen Death from Above
16. Grizzly Bear - Knife
15. Dirty Projectors - Two Young Sheeps
14. Beach House - Master of None
13. Band of Horses - The Funeral
12. St. Vincent - Paris is Burning
11. White Denim - Let's Talk About It
10. Ghostface Killah - Whip You With a Strap
9. Liars - The Other Side of Mt. Heart Attack
8. Destroyer - Painter in Your Pocket mp3
7. T.I. - What You Know
6. TV On The Radio - Wolf Like Me
5. Sparrow House - When I Am Gone
4. Joanna Newsom - Monkey and Bear
3. The Knife - We Share Our Mother's Health
2. Peter Bjorn & John - Young Folks
1. Midlake - Roscoe

I'm feeling too lazy to post the other lists

EOY 2007 - Albums:

http://gorillavsbear.blogspot.com/2007/12/favorite-records-of-2007.html

EOY 2007 - Songs:

http://gorillavsbear.blogspot.com/2007/12/favorite-songs-of-2007.html

EOY 2008 - Albums:

http://gorillavsbear.blogspot.com/2008/12/gorilla-vs-bears-albums-of-2008.html

EOY 2008 - Songs:

http://gorillavsbear.blogspot.com/2008/12/gorilla-vs-bears-songs-of-2008.html

The 2008, 2007 and 2006 lists are by a single critic.

Sorry to bring this up again, but I'm fairly sure the 2009 list was also made by a single critic. The end of decade list might be from the two contributors though, but two is still not a whole lot.