Put a Pin on the Map View my Forum Guestmap
Free Guestmaps by Bravenet.com

The Old Acclaimed Music Forum

Go to the NEW FORUM

Music, music, music...
Start a New Topic 
1 2
Author
Comment
View Entire Thread
Will...

my favorite act claim at least one position on the top 500 songs list? lol Pitchfork seems to like her earlier material more. I don't see her having an entry on its top 200 albums (even though a couple were pretty darn good).

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

Yankee Hotel Foxtrot may not have made their top ten for the decades first half, but it did score a perfect 10 out of 10. Same for Funeral. It didn't do so well on the same list, but it did get a 9.7 out of 10. This means that their opinions of these albums change frequently. In Rainbows will probably do great because Pitchfork worships the shit out of Radiohead.

All I'm saying is, opinions change, and I really wouldn't go by their list for the beginning of the decade.

Re: Will...

Asking the question 'Would your top 200 go into 3.5 star albums' is a misleading question to me because I didn't start buying huge amounts of new music until 2005. So whereas I don't have 20 4 star and above albums from 2000-2004 I probably do from 2005-2009. Had I been buying huge amounts of music the whole decade, I probably would have a whole top 200 worth of 4 star albums.

For professional music critics who listen to thousands of albums a year, it should be easy to fill a top 200. (Just hard to choose which borderline ones to leave out.)

Re: Will...

How can you listen to 1000s of albums a year? There are only 365 days. That's all you'd get done.

Re: Will...

I think the main thing to note is that when they do lists, they poll current staff members. So, the consensus opinion will change from the first half list and definitely will change from the original review.

Re: Will...

JR, I think "Hung Up" has a decent shot to make the list. I'd put Confessions on a Dancefloor and American Life in my list, but I doubt Pitchfork will.

Re: Will...

ChrisF
How can you listen to 1000s of albums a year? There are only 365 days. That's all you'd get done.


Here's how.

First, you look up the definition of hyperbole in the dictionary.

Then, you listen to thousands of albums in a year.

Re: Will...

I listen to about 10 albums a day while working, that would equal 1000s by the end of the year.

Re: Will...

BillAdama
ChrisF
How can you listen to 1000s of albums a year? There are only 365 days. That's all you'd get done.


Here's how.

First, you look up the definition of hyperbole in the dictionary.

Then, you listen to thousands of albums in a year.


BillAdama! Coming alive!

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

Wow, then we have a year (60's) to digest the list it before we do the 00's (year polls) here on AM.

In my eyes, rock died a little, albumwise, the last few years. Some favorites from the decade:

Strokes - This Is It
Jeff Buckley - Grace
Bob Hund - Omslag: Martin Kann
White Stripes - White Blood Cells/Elephant
Strokes - Is This It?
Ryan Adams - Love Is Hell
Arcade Fire - Funeral
Sufjan Stevens - Illinois
Richard Hawley - Cole's Corner

Favorite songs of the decade?

New Pornographers - All The Things That Go To Make Heaven And Earth
Ryan Adams - Anybody Wanna Take Me Home
Phoenix - Love Like A Sunset
Amon Tobin - Lighthouse
Strapping Young Lad - Imperial

Yeah...

"Hung Up" received much acclaim-it was No. 26 on Pitchfork's year-end list, but I guess it will depend if they poll newer critics, whatnot. Surprised "Music" wasn't on the 2000 year-end listing.

COADF would be on mine, but I don't enjoy American Life quite as much. Neither Music or COADF Placed on Pitchfork's year-end lists, so, yeah, I guess they won't appear.

Re: Yeah...

Anyway most of the top 100 songs will be songs already in the Pitchfork 500 or the addendum for songs of 2007, especially with 2008 quite a weak single year (with Blind and Ready for the Floor probably quite high however).
The few songs released before which will make the top 100 without being in the top 100 will be songs cut because of the rule "only one song by album" (for instance it is pretty sure that Ms Jackson and B.O.B. will both be high will only one was on the Pitchfork 100 )

Anyway, what is sure is that their communication plan is very efficient since all of us music geek have been buzzing about their list for one week.

Re: Yeah...

I hate it how lupe fiasco never gets the attention that he deserves from all of these lists.

Re: Yeah...

It's surprisingly hard to get back into the loop with this forum, when going away on holiday, and being without internet access!

I'd be interested to see where Turn on the Bright Lights turns up in the list. It came top in the year, v. high in the halfdecade list, and is without a doubt one of my favourite albums from this decade. Yet I get theimpression firstly that it was criminally underrated when it first came out (mainly by other publications), but has also slightly lost favour with pitchfork. I have no doubt Kid A will come up trumps - the only possible album to challenge it being Person Pitch. Funeral should challenge it, but I get the impression PF won't rate it as highly as they should.

I also completely agree with Stevo- Lupe Fiasco does not get the recognition he deserves - he is probably my favourite hip-hop act, after outkast and cannibal ox of the decade.

Re: Yeah...

It will be:

1. MPP
2. Sung Tongs
3. Feels
4. Strawberry Jam
5. Here Comes The Indian
6. Campfire Songs
7. Spirit They're Gone, Spirit They've Vanished
8. Danse Manatee
9. Oh no, we ran out of Animal Collective albums! :(
10. Oh no, we ran out of Animal Collective albums! :(

GOD, I hate that band.

Re: Yeah...

And I hate Pitchfork! Is it possible to be any more pretentious?

Re: Yeah...

ChrisF
And I hate Pitchfork! Is it possible to be any more pretentious?


www.scaruffi.com



good music's good music.

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

Songs 201-500 are up now!

http://pitchfork.com/features/staff-lists/7685-the-top-500-tracks-of-the-2000s-500-201/

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

Two of my favorites from this decade, "Daniel" by Bat For Lashes and "Danger! High Voltage" by Electric Six, were in this section; I'd thought they'd rank a little higher. (oh well, it is only 1 list after all)

Also, glad to see "The Next Episode" by Dr. Dre get some love. Hey Hey, Hey Hey...

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

Some songs I'm glad to see (would be in my top 200 of the decade)
The Dodos - Fools (which I expected higher but well, great song anyway)
Sufjan Stevens - For The Widows in Paradise (one of Sufjan finest song, a bit overshadowed by songs from Illinoise)
DFA 1979 - Romantic Rights (one of the best riffs of the decade)
Soulwax - NY Excuse
The Roots - Seed 2.0
Vampire Weekend - Walcott (best track of the album for me)
Midlake - Roscoe (the album has been quite a deception but that song is incredibly beautiful)
Gorillaz - Feel Good Inc.
CSS - Let's Make Love and Listen to Death From Above
And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead - Another Morning Stoner (since it was in the Pitchfork 500, I hope it would make the top 200... one of the best non QOTSA heavy song of the decade)
The Books - Take Time (another Pitchfork 500 out ! )
At the Drive-In - One Armed Scissor (not the best song of Relationship of Command but the most acclaimed one for an unknown reason)
The Thermals - A Pillar of Salt (probably the best surprise so far, it is here ranked 250 but for me it is top 50 of the decade, it is epic, intense but very funny and danceable too with this high-speed riff and those very powerful lyrics)

I thought Sleeping Giant will reach the top 200 since it is in the Pitchfork 500 but it is not even on the top 400... quite a surprise for me ! Surprised to by the low rank of The Moon by the Microphones.

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

Happy to see:

N.E.R.D.- "Run to the Sun"
Björk- "New World"
Death from Above 1979- "Romantic Rights"
Gwen Stefani- "What You Waiting For" (easily her best song)
Yeah Yeah Yeahs- "Cheated Hearts"
Missy Elliott- "Pass That Dutch"
PJ Harvey- "Good Fortune"
Rachel Stevens- "Some Girls"
Girls Aloud- "Biology"
Björk- "Pagan Poetry" (would make my top 10)
Kylie Minogue- "Love At First Sight"
Bat for Lashes- "Daniel" (I agree it should be higher than 206)

Horrified to see:

Lumidee- "I'll Never Leave You": It's hard to come across a more out of tune voice.
Destiny's Child- "Jumpin' Jumpin'" (pure trash)

And JR, "Don't Tell Me" lands at number 434!

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

Good to see:
Weezer - Island in the Sun
Decemberists - The Engine Driver
Coldplay - Yellow (expected a shutout of their stuff)
Cut Copy - Out There on the Ice

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

I was surprised to see "While You Wait For the Others" by Grizzly Bear so low. I mean didn't they give it a 10?

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

Ned
I was surprised to see "While You Wait For the Others" by Grizzly Bear so low. I mean didn't they give it a 10?


I expected it to T50. Maybe they'll rank something like Two Weeks or Cheerleader high. I doubt they're going to scorn Grizzly Bear. Also expected to see Daniel and Intervention higher.

Also to keep a record; one Radiohead song, one Arcade Fire song, one OutKast song, 0 Animal Collective songs, 0 LCD Soundsystem songs. I think those bands are going to be more clustered at the top.

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

I don't recognize this music. I'm out of time!

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

I always like these singles lists the best because it reveals more music to me that I haven't heard. I had never heard the Emily Haines, Mum or Jesu songs and listening to the rest of the albums or EP's on rateyourmusic gave me a few new albums to listen to because they sound great.

The List...

takes too long to load on my system- thanks for posting some of the inclusions.

And thanks for the Madge report, Moonbeam. :) I guess "Hung Up" could crack the top 200.

Re: The List...

200-101

191. Vampire Weekend - Oxford Comma
190. Panjabi MC - Mundian to Bach Ke (is Jay-Z even in this song?)
184. Queens of the Stone Age - No One Knows
179. Bon Iver - Skinny Love (I like For Emma Better)
177. Eminem - The Real Slim Shady
175. Usher - Yeah!
165. Jimmy Eat World - The Middle
160. 50 Cent - In Da Club - How is this not in the Top 100?
157. Kanye West - Touch the Sky
151. Santogold - LES Artistes
150. Junior Senior - Move Your Feet (maybe they just don't like songs from earlier in the decade as much)
143. Feist - 1234
142. Flaming Lips - Do You Realize???
141. Britney Spears - Toxic (she can't sing, but good music)
139. Daft Punk - Better, Harder, Faster, Stronger
135. The Strokes - The Modern Age
131. Destiny's Child - Say My Name
129. Andrew WK - Party Hard
124. Ted Leo and the Pharmacists - Where Have All the Rude Boys Gone?
119. TI - Rubber Band Man (this is definitely not his best)
116. The White Stripes - Dead Leaves and the Dirty Ground
114. !!! - Me and Giuliani Down By the Schoolyard (A True Story)
104. Eminem - Lose Yourself (My favorite of 2002)

Re: The List...

Songs I expected higher (all top 100 for me) :
Joana Newsom - Peach Plum Pear (only 197 ? it is in incredibly cheerful song with an amazing melody)
Vitalic - la Rock 02 (may be the best electro song of the decade)
Sufjan Stevens - Casimir Pulaski Day
Justice - We Are Your Friends
Kanye West - Jesus Walks
Animal Collective - Leaf House (well, there will probably be Fireworks and My Girls on the top 100, which I really like too, but Leaf House and Purple Bottle are top 100 too for me... while Grass, which might be on their list, is not)
Dizzee Rascal - Fix Up Look Sharp (but I Luv U is still running ! )

Very good surprise (top 100 for me but which I didn't expect to see)
Dirty Projectors - Stillness is the Move (one of the top 3 songs of 2009, strange mix of guitars, hip-hop and oriental groove, awesome !)
The Pipettes - Pull Shapes (almost as irresistible as Rosey)

WTF :
Jimmy Eat World - The Middle : seriously ???? it is not even fun in Guitar Hero !

And I'm also glad to see Mushaboom topping 1234

Re: The List...

Great list so far.
Second part (200-101)
Many pleasant surprises here too
Our Way to Fall, The Other Side of Mt. Heart Attack, Pull Shapes, You Are the Generation That Bought More Shoes and You Get What You Deserve(#121!!!!) and Lloyd, I'm Ready to Be Heartbroken to name a few.
Expected to be in top 100 Leafhouse (!!??) & Stillness is the Move (the song of the year?). Peach Plum Pear is also my favourite Joanna Newsom song but there might be still left Cosmia, Colleen or Emily (or not).
Only one Radiohead (& Animal Collective) song so far. I expected more.

Re: The List...

YAY!
#447: Mylo - "In My Arms" (vastly better than "Drop the Pressure")
#341: Fleet Foxes - "Blue Ridge Mountains" (second best off the album after "Quiet Houses")
#303: Mystikal - "Shake Ya Ass" (hate me for it, but I love it)
#239: The Dismemberment Plan - "The Face of the Earth" (YES!)
#185: Dead Prez - "Hip Hop" (love to see these guys getting some props)
#169: Ludacris - "Southern Hospitality" (I forgot that this was from the '00s)
#157: Kanye West - "Touch the Sky" (really underrated cut)
#122: Cam'ron - "Hey Ma" (why was "Oh Boy" the bigger single?)
#118: Camera Obscura - "Lloyd, I'm Ready to Be Heartbroken"
#105: Grinderman - "No Pussy Blues" (one of the funniest songs in a LONG time)





BOO!
#495: Weezer - "Island in the Sun" (so incredibly blah)
#351: Rich Boy - "Throw Some D's" (I swear, the only words are "throw some d's on that bitch")
#276: The Darkness - "I Believe in a Thing Called Love" (never liked it)
#219: Lil Mama - "Lip Gloss"
#180: Gwen Stefani - "Hollaback Girl" (what can be said about this that hasn't already been said?)
#175: Usher et al. - "Yeah!"
#131: Destiny's Child - "Say My Name"


Not sure which side of the fence I'm falling on with Andrew W.K. or Kelis...

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

ericb
Funeral will not be #1. It was #45 in their 2000-2004 list.


Pitchfork has a way of changing around their preferences a lot, year to year - and list to list. How many songs from the last Pitchfork 500 has come out with low scores on this last list? I haven't counted, but there are many...

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

Happy to see:

Morrissey- "First of the Gang to Die"
Xiu Xiu- "I Love the Valley OH!"
Ladytron- "Destroy Everything You Touch"- so powerful!
The Strokes- "The Modern Age"
!!!- "Me and Giuliani Down by the Schoolyard": Expected this to be a bit higher, but it's just awesome.
Aaliyah- "We Need a Resolution": I'm hoping "Try Again" cracks the top 100.

Appalled to see:

Twista- "Slow Jamz": How this gets acclaim is beyond me!
Beyonce- "Irreplaceable"
Usher- "Yeah": No.
50 Cent- "In da Club": Hip hop's worst artist
Destiny's Child- "Say My Name"

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

So far, I think this list is really good. 2 more songs for Grizzly Bear in this section probably means none in the T100, unless they put something like Cheerleader up there but I think that's unlikely. They put down a second Strokes song, so I think Last Nite will crack T100. Dead Leaves and Dirty Ground (one of my favorites) is the first Stripes song, meaning that Seven Nation Army and Fell In Love With A Girl definately made the list. Although 7NA will likely finish a lot lower than Fell in Love.

Animal Collective puts up their first song with Leaf House. I suspect they still have another 2-3 songs in the T100 and that My Girls may T10. Radiohead and OutKast didn't get a song in this update leaving both artists with 1. Nonetheless, it would be unthinkable to have a T100 without Pyramid Song, There There, Ms. Jackson, Hey Ya, and BOB, the latter two will likely T10. Also, there have been 0 LCD Soundsystem songs so far. I wouldn't be shocked if as many as 5 were included in the T100. Here's my hypothetical T10

1. All My Friends
2. B.O.B
3. Hey Ya
4. Blind
5. Losing My Edge
6. Heartbeat
7. My Girls
8. Fell In Love with a Girl
9. Battles
10. Maps

Songs are harder to predict than albums, but I think this one is pretty solid.

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

SR
So far, I think this list is really good. 2 more songs for Grizzly Bear in this section probably means none in the T100, unless they put something like Cheerleader up there but I think that's unlikely. They put down a second Strokes song, so I think Last Nite will crack T100. Dead Leaves and Dirty Ground (one of my favorites) is the first Stripes song, meaning that Seven Nation Army and Fell In Love With A Girl definately made the list. Although 7NA will likely finish a lot lower than Fell in Love.

Animal Collective puts up their first song with Leaf House. I suspect they still have another 2-3 songs in the T100 and that My Girls may T10. Radiohead and OutKast didn't get a song in this update leaving both artists with 1. Nonetheless, it would be unthinkable to have a T100 without Pyramid Song, There There, Ms. Jackson, Hey Ya, and BOB, the latter two will likely T10. Also, there have been 0 LCD Soundsystem songs so far. I wouldn't be shocked if as many as 5 were included in the T100. Here's my hypothetical T10

1. All My Friends
2. B.O.B
3. Hey Ya
4. Blind
5. Losing My Edge
6. Heartbeat
7. My Girls
8. Fell In Love with a Girl
9. Battles
10. Maps

Songs are harder to predict than albums, but I think this one is pretty solid.


Not sure about two Outkast songs being 2 and 3, but they did go 1-2 last time. Don't sleep on Bro's, that's the kind of song Pitchfork would love in the top 10.

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

I wish you could scan a song with Lala.

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

Scott
SR
So far, I think this list is really good. 2 more songs for Grizzly Bear in this section probably means none in the T100, unless they put something like Cheerleader up there but I think that's unlikely. They put down a second Strokes song, so I think Last Nite will crack T100. Dead Leaves and Dirty Ground (one of my favorites) is the first Stripes song, meaning that Seven Nation Army and Fell In Love With A Girl definately made the list. Although 7NA will likely finish a lot lower than Fell in Love.

Animal Collective puts up their first song with Leaf House. I suspect they still have another 2-3 songs in the T100 and that My Girls may T10. Radiohead and OutKast didn't get a song in this update leaving both artists with 1. Nonetheless, it would be unthinkable to have a T100 without Pyramid Song, There There, Ms. Jackson, Hey Ya, and BOB, the latter two will likely T10. Also, there have been 0 LCD Soundsystem songs so far. I wouldn't be shocked if as many as 5 were included in the T100. Here's my hypothetical T10

1. All My Friends
2. B.O.B
3. Hey Ya
4. Blind
5. Losing My Edge
6. Heartbeat
7. My Girls
8. Fell In Love with a Girl
9. Battles
10. Maps

Songs are harder to predict than albums, but I think this one is pretty solid.


Not sure about two Outkast songs being 2 and 3, but they did go 1-2 last time. Don't sleep on Bro's, that's the kind of song Pitchfork would love in the top 10.


I don't think Atlas will make the top 10.
And I'm pretty sure too that Bro's will.
I would not bet on Maps or Fell In Love With A Girl either, maybe more on Wolf Like Me, Idioteque and Get Ur Freak On.

Anyway, hope Boy From School will make the top 20 (and songs from the Knife and others songs from Hot Chip on the top 100 would be great too)

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

Nassim
Scott
SR
So far, I think this list is really good. 2 more songs for Grizzly Bear in this section probably means none in the T100, unless they put something like Cheerleader up there but I think that's unlikely. They put down a second Strokes song, so I think Last Nite will crack T100. Dead Leaves and Dirty Ground (one of my favorites) is the first Stripes song, meaning that Seven Nation Army and Fell In Love With A Girl definately made the list. Although 7NA will likely finish a lot lower than Fell in Love.

Animal Collective puts up their first song with Leaf House. I suspect they still have another 2-3 songs in the T100 and that My Girls may T10. Radiohead and OutKast didn't get a song in this update leaving both artists with 1. Nonetheless, it would be unthinkable to have a T100 without Pyramid Song, There There, Ms. Jackson, Hey Ya, and BOB, the latter two will likely T10. Also, there have been 0 LCD Soundsystem songs so far. I wouldn't be shocked if as many as 5 were included in the T100. Here's my hypothetical T10

1. All My Friends
2. B.O.B
3. Hey Ya
4. Blind
5. Losing My Edge
6. Heartbeat
7. My Girls
8. Fell In Love with a Girl
9. Battles
10. Maps

Songs are harder to predict than albums, but I think this one is pretty solid.


Not sure about two Outkast songs being 2 and 3, but they did go 1-2 last time. Don't sleep on Bro's, that's the kind of song Pitchfork would love in the top 10.


I don't think Atlas will make the top 10.
And I'm pretty sure too that Bro's will.
I would not bet on Maps or Fell In Love With A Girl either, maybe more on Wolf Like Me, Idioteque and Get Ur Freak On.

Anyway, hope Boy From School will make the top 20 (and songs from the Knife and others songs from Hot Chip on the top 100 would be great too)


Instead of Wolf Like Me, probably Staring At The Sun. I've felt that All My Friends is a shoo-in, but i'm surprised to see that the general consensus is in favour of it. Is it not only my favourite song from the past decade?

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

All My Friends is a modern classic. It topped the singles list for 2007, a very competitive year, and from what I can tell concensus opinion has only grown more favorable.

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

well, i was thinking along the lines of people's favourites, not significance. It seems like Pitchfork aren't thinking significance as much as they usually do, this time round. I think one reason many of the entries to last year's PF 500 have got relatively low placements now, is that the purpose of the decades list is somewhat different.

Anyone wants to take a go at placing All My Friends genre-wise, cause dance-punk it ain't

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

Dance-Prog?

Moonbeam...

do you think "Hung Up" will get slighted for this list? Look at Britney Spears' "Toxic" (one of just two singles of hers that receives acclaim, none of her albums do). It was no. 3 on Pitchfork's year-end list and #13 on the half-decade list.

You never know how things will turn out with decade lists, though.

And what is wrong with "Irreplaceable"? It's one of my favorite mainstream tracks from the last several years.

Re: Moonbeam...

JR, I think "Hung Up" will make the top 100. It certainly deserves a nod. "Toxic" did go very far down the list, which makes me worry about the placements of "Can't Get You Out of My Head", "Hung Up" and "My Heartbeat". We shall see!

As for Beyonce, I think she is Satan incarnate. That doesn't mean I haven't used her to teach my students before! They know the Standard Normal table as Beyonce, because students tend not to look at the key and by making a fool out of myself singing "to the left, to the left, every single time the Standard Normal's to the left- don't you ever for a second get to thinkin' it's to the right", it helps them remember.

Re: Moonbeam...

As for "All My Friends", I'm pulling for it to take the crown. It is my 2nd or 3rd favorite song of the decade (after Annie's "My Heartbeat" and perhaps Kylie's "Can't Get You Out of My Head"), and it easily places among my top 30 songs ever.

Re: Moonbeam...

Haha harsh on Sasha, ain't ya? hehe She's ubiquitous, but I like some of her songs. asn't too big on "Single Ladies"- overall, I like the restained, softer Beyonce music, I guess. Though "Crazy in Love" is a great single, and I liked "Deja Vu."

Did Pitchfork not publish year-end lists in 2000/2001? Can't find that it did on this site. Did it start in 2003, even though it claims to have been around for the whole of this decade's music?

Re: Moonbeam...

it did list for albums but not singles 2000-2002. all lists are on the left towards the bottom of the main page

Re: Moonbeam...

51. Jay Z - Takeover
52. Kanye West feat Dwele - Flashing Lights
53. The Strokes - Someday
54. Missy Elliott - Work It
55. OutKast - Ms Jackson - (How is this so low?)
56. Dizzee Rascal - I Luv U
57. TV on the Radio - Wolf Like Me
58. The White Stripes - Fell in Love With a Girl
59. Radiohead - Pyramid Song
60. Ghostface Killah - Nutmeg
61. Wilco - Jesus, etc
62. The Shins - New Slang
63. The Hold Steady - Stuck Between Stations
64. Interpol - Obstacle 1 - (one of my favorites)
65. Justin Timberlake - Cry Me a River
66. Fleet Foxes - White Winter Hymnal - (I thought it would be higher)
67. Band of Horses - The Funeral
68. Dr Dre feat Eminem - Forgot About Dre
69. Arcade Fire - Rebellion (Lies)
70. Junior Boys feat Andi Toma - In the Morning
71. Kanye West feat Consequence and Cam'ron - Gone
72. The Killers - Mr. Brightside - (glad to see it in the top 100)
73. Animal Collective - Grass
74. The Knife - Silent Shout
75. Aaliyah - Try Again
76. Hot Chip - Ready For the Floor
77. Three 6 Mafia - Stay Fly
78. Freelance Hellraiser - A Stroke of Genius
79. Jay Z - Izzo (HOVA)
80. Lil Wayne - A Milli
81. Deerhunter - Nothing Ever Happened
82. Robyn - Be Mine
83. Basement Jaxx - Where's Your Head At
84. Peter Bjorn and John - Young Folks
85. Phoenix - Long Distance Call
86. Mclusky - To Hell With Good Intentions
87. Mike Jones - Still Tippin'
88. The New Pornographers - Letter From an Occupant
89. The Postal Service - Such Great Heights
90. The Streets - Weak Become Heroes
91. Justice - DANCE
92. Modest Mouse - 3rd Planet
93. The Game feat 50 Cent - Hate It or Love It
94. The Futureheads - Hounds of Love
95. Wolf Parade - I'll Believe in Anything
96. Clinic - Distortions
97. Belle and Sebastian - I'm a Cuckoo (by the Avalanches)
98. Beirut - Postcards from Italy
99. MGMT - Time to Pretend (I was thinking top 25)
100. Jamey Lidell - Multiply

Re: Moonbeam...

Thrilled to see "Try Again" at 75. It totally deserves it! I'm a little surprised to see "Ms. Jackson", "Wolf Like Me" and "Fell in Love with a Girl" so soon, but if it means that "Can't Get You Out of My Head" and "My Heartbeat" are in the top 50, I'm all for it.

I'm surprised that no LCD Soundsystem songs have made it. It seems unlikely that they'll get more than 2 in the top 50. Can "Someone Great" sneak in? Or "Yeah"?

Re: Moonbeam...

Glad to see Wilco getting decent singles praise (3 on the list thus far.)

Generally, they're all album praise and no single praise. "Jesus, Etc" and "Poor Places" are monsters though.

Re: Moonbeam...

Ghostface Killah at 60? Cherchez LaGhost is a better song,but neither are top 100 worthy.

Re: Moonbeam...

Chris
51. Jay Z - Takeover
52. Kanye West feat Dwele - Flashing Lights
53. The Strokes - Someday
54. Missy Elliott - Work It
55. OutKast - Ms Jackson - (How is this so low?)
56. Dizzee Rascal - I Luv U
57. TV on the Radio - Wolf Like Me
58. The White Stripes - Fell in Love With a Girl
59. Radiohead - Pyramid Song
60. Ghostface Killah - Nutmeg
61. Wilco - Jesus, etc
62. The Shins - New Slang
63. The Hold Steady - Stuck Between Stations
64. Interpol - Obstacle 1 - (one of my favorites)
65. Justin Timberlake - Cry Me a River
66. Fleet Foxes - White Winter Hymnal - (I thought it would be higher)
67. Band of Horses - The Funeral
68. Dr Dre feat Eminem - Forgot About Dre
69. Arcade Fire - Rebellion (Lies)
70. Junior Boys feat Andi Toma - In the Morning
71. Kanye West feat Consequence and Cam'ron - Gone
72. The Killers - Mr. Brightside - (glad to see it in the top 100)
73. Animal Collective - Grass
74. The Knife - Silent Shout
75. Aaliyah - Try Again
76. Hot Chip - Ready For the Floor
77. Three 6 Mafia - Stay Fly
78. Freelance Hellraiser - A Stroke of Genius
79. Jay Z - Izzo (HOVA)
80. Lil Wayne - A Milli
81. Deerhunter - Nothing Ever Happened
82. Robyn - Be Mine
83. Basement Jaxx - Where's Your Head At
84. Peter Bjorn and John - Young Folks
85. Phoenix - Long Distance Call
86. Mclusky - To Hell With Good Intentions
87. Mike Jones - Still Tippin'
88. The New Pornographers - Letter From an Occupant
89. The Postal Service - Such Great Heights
90. The Streets - Weak Become Heroes
91. Justice - DANCE
92. Modest Mouse - 3rd Planet
93. The Game feat 50 Cent - Hate It or Love It
94. The Futureheads - Hounds of Love
95. Wolf Parade - I'll Believe in Anything
96. Clinic - Distortions
97. Belle and Sebastian - I'm a Cuckoo (by the Avalanches)
98. Beirut - Postcards from Italy
99. MGMT - Time to Pretend (I was thinking top 25)
100. Jamey Lidell - Multiply


73. Animal Collective - Grass
74. The Knife - Silent Shout
75. Aaliyah - Try Again
76. Hot Chip - Ready For the Floor
Awesome serie ! Especially since I really dislike the #72, Mr Brightside.

Lot of Pitchfork 500 as expected but some great surprises, especially Jesus, Etc (and I guess that will be an opinion wildly shared in the forum).

And well, I expected Fell In Love With a Girl to be in the top 50 and Mrs Jackson to be in the top 10. Biggest disappointment for the moment, I'm sorry Mrs Jackson ! I am for real !

Re:

98. Beirut - Postcards from Italy
is maybe the best surprise of this part. It's the only reason I still listen to Gulag Orkester occasionally (and right now).
It's also maybe only (pleasant) surprise in this part (well if Robyn has two songs in top 100 it's surprise as well)
Several my favourites are just were I expected them to be (the songs Nassim mentioned (Try Again is maybe best R&B song of the decade) + In the Morning(!!), Such Great Hights etc.)
I'm very surprised and disappointed that there are every bad song from Bracketology which I thought would have vanished after decade lists (Usher, The Game, Futureheads, Madonna (I can't stand Don't Tell Me) etc. There are so many mainstream songs in the list that it makes me wonder have Pitchfork changed their staff.

Re: Re:

pop elton
98. Beirut - Postcards from Italy
is maybe the best surprise of this part. It's the only reason I still listen to Gulag Orkester occasionally (and right now).
It's also maybe only (pleasant) surprise in this part (well if Robyn has two songs in top 100 it's surprise as well)
Several my favourites are just were I expected them to be (the songs Nassim mentioned (Try Again is maybe best R&B song of the decade) + In the Morning(!!), Such Great Hights etc.)
I'm very surprised and disappointed that there are every bad song from Bracketology which I thought would have vanished after decade lists (Usher, The Game, Futureheads, Madonna (I can't stand Don't Tell Me) etc. There are so many mainstream songs in the list that it makes me wonder have Pitchfork changed their staff.


I forgot In The Morning, love it too, probably the only reason I sometimes listen to this album.
And Such Great Heights is a great song too.

I don't get the acclaim on Rebellion Lies which is my least favourite song on Funeral.

Nooo...

"Don't Tell Me" is one of her best tracks, period- is there anything you like from this Madge decade? :)

Moonbeam, I'm starting to think Pitchfork passed on "Hung Up" for this year-end tally- top 50 would be too high based on its year-end placement, but, one never knows. Are there any examples thus far of songs that didn't place all that highly on year-end lists, that have done so on this list?

Couple Examples...

"Lip Gloss" (a WTF selection to me) ranked 27th on the year-end list, and 219 on this decade list; Robyn's "Be Mine" ranked 21st on the year-end list, and 82nd on the decade list. Then you had Britney Spears' "Toxic" ranking 3rd on the year-end list, but "only" 141 on the decade list.

So, again, who knows.

Yeees! :)

JR
"Don't Tell Me" is one of her best tracks, period- is there anything you like from this Madge decade? :)

I like Music (the song). What It Feels Like for a Girl (especially the music video+remix) and that James Bond song were good too. But after Bond song she hasn't released a single song I like.
I saw Madonna live couble of weeks ago (the ticket cost over €100 (almost $150). What a waste!). I noticed that it's not just the songs of this decade but I didn't like the older songs either (it must be the new arrangements). Only 'You Must Love Me' and 'Ray of Light' (and somehow 4 Minutes) sounded great.

Re: Moonbeam...

Chris

55. OutKast - Ms Jackson
57. TV on the Radio - Wolf Like Me
58. The White Stripes - Fell in Love With a Girl


The low positions of these songs simply means that the groups other songs performed better. I'm not at all surprised by Ms Jackson's placement. I think it deserves higher, but I'm sure Hey Ya and BOB will T10 so it's whatever. Wolf Like Me at probably means Staring at the Sun will be higher.

When I saw Fell in Love's low placement though, my jaw nearly dropped. I guess pitchfork have reversed their position on the Stripes, and decided that 7NA is the better song. I know they aren't the biggest fans of Jack, but surely it's impossible to have a T500 songs list without Seven Nation Army.

Re: Moonbeam...

50-21 is up
50. Basement Jaxx - "Romeo"
49. Sufjan Stevens - "Chicago"
48. Panda Bear - "Bro's"
47. Burial - "Archangel"
46. Robyn [ft. Kleerup] - "With Every Heartbeat"
45. Hot Chip - "Over and Over"
44. Franz Ferdinand - "Take Me Out"
43. UGK [ft. Outkast] - "Int'l Players Anthem (I Choose You)"
42. Battles - "Atlas"
41. TV on the Radio - "Staring at the Sun"
40. The Avalanches - "Since I Left You"
39. Modest Mouse - "Float On"
38. T.I. - "What You Know"
37. Kylie Minogue - "Can't Get You Out of My Head"
36. Sigur Rós - "Svefn-G-Englar"
35. Animal Collective - "Fireworks"
34. M.I.A. - "Galang"
33. Spoon - "The Way We Get By"
32. Amerie - "1 Thing"
31. Jay-Z [ft. UGK] - "Big Pimpin'"
30. The White Stripes - "Seven Nation Army"
29. Hot Chip - "Boy From School"
28. Antony and the Johnsons - "Hope There's Someone"
27. Clipse - "Grindin'"
26. Justin Timberlake [ft. T.I.] - "My Love"
25. Rihanna [ft. Jay-Z] - "Umbrella"
24. Radiohead - "Everything in Its Right Place"
23. Daft Punk - "Digital Love"
22. LCD Soundsystem - "Someone Great"
21. Kelly Clarkson - "Since U Been Gone"

Re: Moonbeam...

Edit: I was beaten to it.

Re: Moonbeam...

Here's my guess for the Top 20. (I know some of these are long shots. / Hopefully nothing was listed already.)

Jay-Z - 99 Problems
LCD Soundsystem - All My Friends
OutKast - B.O.B. (Bombs Over Baghdad)
Hercules and Love Affair - Blind
Gnarls Barkley - Crazy
Beyonce - Crazy in Love
Missy Elliott - Get Ur Freak On
Kanye West - Gold Digger
Annie - Heartbeat
OutKast - Hey Ya!
The Rapture - House of Jealous Lovers
R. Kelly - Ignition (Remix)
MGMT - Kids
M83 - Kim & Jessie
LCD Soundsystem - Losing My Edge
Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Maps
Animal Collective - My Girls
M.I.A. - Paper Planes
Amy Winehouse - Rehab
Damian "Jr Gong" Marley - Welcome to Jamrock

50-21

Happy to see:

Robyn- "With Every Heartbeat"
Franz Ferdinand- "Take Me Out": This being at number 44 is quite a surprise though- I feel it should have been in the top 20, and it seems that Franz will indeed slide down the AM lists
Modest Mouse- "Float On"
Kylie- "Can't Get You Out of My Head": Number 37 is a pretty decent showing, even if it would be in my top 3
Clipse- "Grindin'": One of the best hip hop tracks of the decade for sure. I'm bummed that Busta Rhymes will strike out, though.
LCD Soundsystem- "Someone Great":Wow! Didn't expect it at number 22, but I'm happy! "All My Friends" seems like a lock for the top 10, now.

Horrified:

Justin Timberlake- "My Love": Timbertwat ruins a nice Timbaland production.
Kelly Clarkson- "Since U Been Gone": Idol twaddle.

Re: Moonbeam...

Chris
Here's my guess for the Top 20. (I know some of these are long shots. / Hopefully nothing was listed already.)

Jay-Z - 99 Problems
LCD Soundsystem - All My Friends
OutKast - B.O.B. (Bombs Over Baghdad)
Hercules and Love Affair - Blind
Gnarls Barkley - Crazy
Beyonce - Crazy in Love
Missy Elliott - Get Ur Freak On
Kanye West - Gold Digger
Annie - Heartbeat
OutKast - Hey Ya!
The Rapture - House of Jealous Lovers
R. Kelly - Ignition (Remix)
MGMT - Kids
M83 - Kim & Jessie
LCD Soundsystem - Losing My Edge
Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Maps
Animal Collective - My Girls
M.I.A. - Paper Planes
Amy Winehouse - Rehab
Damian "Jr Gong" Marley - Welcome to Jamrock


I think you've just about nailed it. M83 and Damian Marley have already placed, though, so there have to be some others we're missing. Thrilled that Annie is likely to be in the top 20! There's no way it'll happen, but I'd love it if her single "Anthonio" gave her two songs in the top 20. "Songs Remind Me of You" wouldn't be a bad choice, either.

Re: Moonbeam...

Moonbeam
Chris
Here's my guess for the Top 20. (I know some of these are long shots. / Hopefully nothing was listed already.)

Jay-Z - 99 Problems
LCD Soundsystem - All My Friends
OutKast - B.O.B. (Bombs Over Baghdad)
Hercules and Love Affair - Blind
Gnarls Barkley - Crazy
Beyonce - Crazy in Love
Missy Elliott - Get Ur Freak On
Kanye West - Gold Digger
Annie - Heartbeat
OutKast - Hey Ya!
The Rapture - House of Jealous Lovers
R. Kelly - Ignition (Remix)
MGMT - Kids
M83 - Kim & Jessie
LCD Soundsystem - Losing My Edge
Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Maps
Animal Collective - My Girls
M.I.A. - Paper Planes
Amy Winehouse - Rehab
Damian "Jr Gong" Marley - Welcome to Jamrock


I think you've just about nailed it. M83 and Damian Marley have already placed, though, so there have to be some others we're missing. Thrilled that Annie is likely to be in the top 20! There's no way it'll happen, but I'd love it if her single "Anthonio" gave her two songs in the top 20. "Songs Remind Me of You" wouldn't be a bad choice, either.


I would bet that the 2 missing songs are(I hope) Heartbeats by the Knife and Idioteque.

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

A few downers for me:

The list is likely not to include Duffy's "Mercy" or Janelle Monae's "Many Moons", both of which deserve to crack the top 500 at the very least.

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

I don't think I've seen Daft Punk's "One More Time" yet, so it could be in top 20 since it's in the Pitchfork 500 book (at least I think it is).

Re: Moonbeam...

Chris
Here's my guess for the Top 20. (I know some of these are long shots. / Hopefully nothing was listed already.)

Jay-Z - 99 Problems
LCD Soundsystem - All My Friends
OutKast - B.O.B. (Bombs Over Baghdad)
Hercules and Love Affair - Blind
Gnarls Barkley - Crazy
Beyonce - Crazy in Love
Missy Elliott - Get Ur Freak On
Kanye West - Gold Digger
Annie - Heartbeat
OutKast - Hey Ya!
The Rapture - House of Jealous Lovers
R. Kelly - Ignition (Remix)
MGMT - Kids
M83 - Kim & Jessie
LCD Soundsystem - Losing My Edge
Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Maps
Animal Collective - My Girls
M.I.A. - Paper Planes
Amy Winehouse - Rehab
Damian "Jr Gong" Marley - Welcome to Jamrock


No way on Marley and M83, and probably not R. Kelly (although I could be wrong on that last one). I think Radiohead has another song in them - can you imagine There There not cracking a T500? and by Pitchfork no less? Also it's possible that this list is LCD Soundsystem domination, and they have something like Yeah or Tribulations on the list.

Re: Moonbeam...

"Someone Great" is actually my favorite LCD Soundsystem song, so I'm happy to see it there. I'm actually surprised that there's been nothing from "Funeral" on the list yet (either that or I didn't look very hard).

Re: Moonbeam...

"Rebellion (Lies)" was in the 60s.

Looks Like...

there will be no "Hung Up" on this list. You'd think it would have been somewhere in thetop 500, being it did place #26 on the 2005 year-end list. Ah, well.

"Can't Get You Out of My Head" appearing was very expected.

Re: Looks Like...

I'm hoping for John Wayne Gacy, Jr.

Re: Moonbeam...

Here's my take on the 00's! As usual you would expect your favorites to be shared with the whole world (Pitchfork)

01 Strokes - Hard To Explain (defined 00's)
02 Zero 7 - Truth And Rights
03 Franz Ferdinand - Take Me Out (Daft Punk remix)
04 Jeff Buckley - Grace
05 Yo La Tengo - Pass The Hatchet, I Think I'm Goodkind
06 Squarepusher - Tetra-Sync
07 Strapping Young Lad - Imperial
08 Ryan Adams - Anybody Wanna Take Me Home
09 Ulrich Schnauss - On My Own (DJ Sasha mix)
10 New Pornographers - All The Things That Go To Make Heaven And Earth
11 TV On The Radio - Young Liars
12 Phoenix - Love Like A Sunset
13 Steely Dan - Almost Gothic
14 Shins - Young Pilgrim
15 Madonna - Hung Up (Durkin mix)
16 Mattias Alkberg BD - Stockholm
17 Trentemöller - Into The Trees (Serenetti, Part 3)
18 Go-Betweens - In Her Diary
19 Walkmen - The Rat
20 White Stripes - Seven Nation Army
21 Cannibal Ox - Iron Galaxy
22 Stereolab - Captain Easychord (2.55 version)
23 LCD Soundsystem - All My Friends
24 Ed Harcourt - Until Tomorrow Then
25 Arcade Fire - Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)
26 Amon Tobin - Lighthouse
27 Edan feat. Mr Lif - Making Planets
28 Elliot Smith - Everything Reminds Me / Means Nothing
29 Belle & Sebastian - We Are The Sleepyheads
30 Sufjan Stevens - John Wayne Gacy, Jr.
31 Richard Hawley - The Ocean
32 Badly Drawn Boy - Magic In The Air
33 Bertrand Burgalat & Robert Wyatt - This Summer Night
34 Agalloch - Bloodbirds
35 Goldfrapp - Lovely Head
36 Cygnus X - Orange Theme (Moonmans Orange Juice mix)
37 Howe Gelb - Chore Of Enchantment
38 Rifles - Repeated Offender
39 Jim James - Calexico - Goin' To Acapulco
40 Mark Lanegan - One Hundred Days
41 Quasimoto - Microphone Mathematic
42 She & Him - Why Do You Let Me Stay Here
43 Madvillain - All Caps
44 Shellac - The End Of Radio
45 Thrills - Hollywood Kids
46 Ulver - Blinded By Blood
47 Mr. Bungle - Pink Cigarette
48 Bob Hund - Våffeljärnet
49 Nellie McKay - Cupcake
50 Mondo Grosso - Star Suite (Shelter Vocal mix)

Re: Looks Like...

Henrik
I'm hoping for John Wayne Gacy, Jr.


That's got to be the first time anyone's ever uttered that sentence ...

Re: Looks Like...

Gahahaha!

Re: Looks Like...

An easier way to look what's on the list...
(Heartbeats by The Knife must be in top 20)

500. The Big Pink "Velvet"
499. N.E.R.D. "Run to the Sun" [Electronic version]
498. Unwound "Scarlette"
497. Woods "Rain On"
496. Akufen "Deck the House (Herbert's Stop Like This Mix)"
495. Weezer "Island in the Sun"
494. Blonde Redhead "Equus"
493. Goldfrapp "Lovely Head"
492. St. Vincent "The Strangers"
491. Viktor Vaughn "Saliva"
490. Closer Musik "Departures"
489. Kano "Reload It"
488. Jesu "Silver"
487. Jaylib "The Red"
486. Spiller [ft. Sophie Ellis-Bextor] "Groovejet (If This Ain't Love)"
485. Ali Farke Touré "Yer Bounda Fara"
484. Múm "Green Grass of Tunnel"
483. Platinum 45 [ft. More Fire Crew] "Oi!"
482. Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds "As I Sat Sadly By Her Side"
481. The Roots "Don't Feel Right"
480. Darkstar "Need You"
479. Brightblack Morning Light "Everybody Daylight"
478. Pantha Du Prince "Asha"
477. Dodos "Fools"
476. Ward 21 "Petrol"
475. Kid Cudi vs. Crookers "Day 'N Night (Remix)"
474. Wolf Eyes "Human Animal"
473. The Concretes "You Can't Hurry Love"
472. Comets on Fire "Wild Whiskey"
471. Crystal Castles "Alice Practice"
470. Orchestra Baobab "Bul Ma Miin"
469. DJ Shadow "You Can't Go Home Again"
468. The Strokes "What Ever Happened?"
467. Rjd2 "Let the Good Times Roll Pt. 2"
466. Saint Etienne "How We Used to Live"
465. Cee-Lo [ft. Timbaland] "I'll Be Around"
464. Voxtrot "The Start of Something"
463. Black Kids "I'm Not Gonna Teach Your Boyfriend How to Dance With You" [EP version]
462. Sun Kil Moon "Carry Me Ohio"
461. Scarface "On My Block"
460. Vivian Girls "Where Do You Run To"
459. The Honeydrips "Fall From a Height (The Field Way)"
458. Sleater-Kinney "Far Away"
457. Emily Haines & the Soft Skeleton "Doctor Blind"
456. Doves "Black and White Town"
455. Bonnie "Prince" Billy "Wolf Among Wolves"
454. Songs: Ohia "Didn't It Rain"
453. Fucked Up "Crusades"
452. Jay Reatard "Always Wanting More"
451. Scissor Sisters "Mary"
450. My Morning Jacket "Golden"
449. Jackson and His Computer Band "Utopia"
448. Lil' Kim [ft. Mr. Cheeks] "The Jump Off"
447. Mylo "In My Arms"
446. M. Ward "Chinese Translation"
445. Ricardo Villalobos "Que Belle Epoque"
444. Be Your Own Pet "Adventure"
443. Explosions in the Sky "First Breath After Coma"
442. Menomena "Wet and Rusting"
441. Sufjan Stevens "For the Widows in Paradise, For the Fathers in Ypsilanti"
440. The Libertines "Time for Heroes"
439. Beirut "Elephant Gun"
438. Lady Sovereign "Ch-Ching (Cheque 1, 2 Remix)"
437. Shackleton "Blood on My Hands"
436. Devendra Banhart "A Sight to Behold"
435. Golden Boy with Miss Kittin "Rippin Kittin"
434. Madonna "Don't Tell Me"
433. DJ Khaled [ft. T.I., Akon, Rick Ross, Fat Joe, Birdman, and Lil Wayne] "We Takin'
Over"
432. Sugababes "Overload"
431. Death Cab for Cutie "The New Year"
430. Mastodon "Sleeping Giant"
429. Gossip "Standing in the Way of Control"
428. Yo La Tengo "Last Days of Disco"
427. Patrick Wolf "The Magic Position"
426. Bob Dylan "Mississippi"
425. Björk "New World"
424. Turbulence "Notorious"
423. The Delgados "All You Need Is Hate"
422. Santogold "Lights Out"
421. Lambchop "Up With People"
420. Schneider TM "The Light 3000"
419. Klaxons "Golden Skans"
418. Ce'cile "Hot Like We"
417. High Places "From Stardust to Sentience"
416. Jens Lekman "The Opposite of Hallelujah"
415. Alicia Keys"You Don't Know My Name (Reggae Remix)"
414. Simian Mobile Disco "It's the Beat" [12" version]
413. Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds "There She Goes, My Beautiful World"
412. Scritti Politti "The Boom Boom Bap"
411. Wilco "Handshake Drugs"
410. Women "Black Rice"
409. Sunn O))) "It Took the Night to Believe"
408. Magik Markers "Taste"
407. Girls on Top "We Don't Give a Damn About Our Friends"
406. Nine Inch Nails "The Hand That Feeds"
405. Superpitcher "Tomorrow"
404. Dinosaur Jr. "Almost Ready"
403. Freeway [ft. Peedi Crakk] "Flipside"
402. My Morning Jacket "Off the Record"
401. The Walkmen "In the New Year"
400. Boris "Ibitsu"
399. Amy Winehouse "Tears Dry on Their Own"
398. The Chemical Brothers "Star Guitar"
397. Queens of the Stone Age "The Lost Art of Keeping a Secret"
396. Nathan Fake "The Sky Was Pink (James Holden Remix)"
395. Death From Above 1979 "Romantic Rights"
394. The Streets "Blinded by the Lights"
393. Lightning Bolt "Dracula Mountain"
392. B15 Project "Girls Like Us"
391. King Khan and the Shrines "Welfare Bread"
390. The Long Blondes "Once and Never Again"
389. Junior Boys "High Come Down"
388. Sigur Rós "Hoppípolla"
387. Cortney Tidwell "Don't Let Stars Keep Us Tangled Up (Ewan's Objects in Space Remix)"
386. Konono No. 1 "Paradiso"
385. Four Tet "My Angel Rocks Back and Forth"
384. Boards of Canada "Music Is Math"
383. Girls "Hellhole Ratrace"
382. The Microphones "The Moon" [Song Islands version]
381. Crime Mob "Knuck If You Buck"
380. Rex the Dog "I Look Into Mid-Air"
379. Goldfrapp "Strict Machine"
378. Blur "Out of Time"
377. Soulwax "NY Excuse"
376. El-P "Stepfather Factory"
375. Röyksopp "What Else Is There?"
374. The Pains of Being Pure at Heart "Young Adult Friction"
373. Cannibal Ox "The F-Word"
372. Camera Obscura "French Navy"
371. Cam'ron [ft. Sarah Hindes] "Get 'Em Girls"
370. Lumidee "I'll Never Leave You (Uh Oooh, Uh Oooh)"
369. Primal Scream "Swastika Eyes"
368. Together "So Much Love to Give"
367. Frightened Rabbit "The Modern Leper"
366. Matthew Dear "Dog Days"
365. Gwen Stefani "What You Waiting For (Thin White Duke Remix)"
364. Elliott Smith "Everything Reminds Me of Her"
363. Clap Your Hands Say Yeah "The Skin of My Yellow Country Teeth"
362. Sigur Rós "Vaka (Untitled 1)"
361. Smog "Rock Bottom Riser"
360. Boards of Canada "In a Beautiful Place Out in the Country"
359. Young Jeezy [ft. Jay-Z] "Go Crazy (Remix)"
358. Cat Power "I Found a Reason"
357. Japandroids "Young Hearts Spark Fire"
356. Jason Forrest "10 Amazing Years"
355. Deerhoof "Milk Man"
354. Tinariwen "Matadjem Yinmixan"
353. Stars of the Lid "Requiem for Dying Mothers (Part 1)"
352. Maxïmo Park "Apply Some Pressure"
351. Rich Boy [ft. Polow Da Don] "Throw Some D's"
350. Man Man "Van Helsing Boombox"
349. Beanie Sigel [ft. Melissa] "Feel It in the Air"
348. Aesop Rock "Daylight"
347. Bonnie "Prince" Billy "Cursed Sleep"
346. Super Furry Animals "Juxtaposed With U"
345. Antony and the Johnsons "Aeon"
344. Lil Wayne "Hustler Musik"
343. The Microphones "The Glow"
342. Franz Ferdinand "Do You Want To"
341. Fleet Foxes "Blue Ridge Mountains"
340. Herbert "Something Isn't Right"
339. Sonic Youth "The Empty Page"
338. The Decemberists "O Valencia!"
337. The National "Mistaken for Strangers"
336. Röyksopp "Eple"
335. Max Tundra "MBGATE"
334. Grizzly Bear "While You Wait for the Others"
333. Death Cab for Cutie "A Movie Script Ending"
332. Aeroplane [ft. Kathy Diamond] "Whispers"
331. Andrew Bird "Fake Palindromes"
330. The Roots [ft. Cody Chestnutt] "The Seed 2.0"
329. Caribou "Hendrix With KO"
328. Isolée "Schrapnell"
327. Vampire Weekend "Walcott"
326. Yeah Yeah Yeahs "Cheated Hearts"
325. Sean Paul "Like Glue"
324. The Twilight Sad "Cold Days From the Birdhouse"
323. The Rapture "I Need Your Love"
322. Wu-Tang Clan "Uzi (Pinky Ring)"
321. Four Tet "Smile Around the Face"
320. Ciara "Promise"
319. Guided by Voices "Chasing Heather Crazy"
318. The Notwist "One With the Freaks"
317. Squarepusher "My Red Hot Car"
316. Neko Case "Hold On, Hold On"
315. Ratatat "17 Years"
314. Metro Area "Miura"
313. The Wrens "She Sends Kisses"
312. The Go! Team "Ladyflash"
311. Sticky [ft. Ms. Dynamite] "Booo!"
310. Okkervil River "For Real"
309. Midlake "Roscoe"
308. Gorillaz "Feel Good Inc."
307. Wolf Parade "Shine a Light"
306. Dr. Dre [ft. Kurupt, Snoop Dogg, and Nate Dogg] "The Next Episode"
305. Loretta Lynn [ft. Jack White] "Portland, Oregon"
304. Destroyer "The Sublimation Hour"
303. Mystikal "Shake Ya Ass"
302. Black Dice "Cone Toaster"
301. The Shins "Kissing the Lipless"
300. Iron & Wine "Upward Over the Mountain"
299. CSS "Let's Make Love and Listen to Death From Above"
298. Stars "Your Ex-Lover Is Dead"
297. David Byrne and Brian Eno "Strange Overtones"
296. Johnny Cash "The Man Comes Around"
295. Grandaddy "The Crystal Lake"
294. Constantines "Night Time (Anytime It's All Right)"
293. Aphex Twin "Avril 14th"
292. Deerhunter "Spring Hall Convert"
291. Missy Elliott "Pass That Dutch"
290. The Exploding Hearts "Modern Kicks"
289. PJ Harvey "Good Fortune"
288. Fabolous "Breathe"
287. Chromatics "In the City"
286. ...And You Will Know Us by the Trail of Dead "Another Morning Stoner"
285. Ryan Adams "Come Pick Me Up"
284. Wiley "Wearing My Rolex"
283. Godspeed You Black Emperor! "Storm" [First Movement]
282. Luomo "The Present Lover" [Digital Disco version]
281. The Books "Take Time"
280. The Fiery Furnaces "Here Comes the Summer"
279. Alan Braxe and Fred Falke "Rubicon"
278. Madvillain "America's Most Blunted"
277. Earth "Coda Maestoso in F (Flat) Minor"
276. The Darkness "I Believe in a Thing Called Love"
275. Broken Social Scene "Stars and Sons"
274. The MFA "The Difference It Makes (Superpitcher Remix)"
273. Smog "Dress Sexy at My Funeral"
272. Nas "One Mic"
271. Arcade Fire "Intervention"
270. Damian Marley "Welcome to Jamrock"
269. The Decemberists "The Engine Driver"
268. Common "The Light"
267. The Beta Band "To You Alone"
266. Bright Eyes "First Day of My Life"
265. Jim O'Rourke "Good Times"
264. Baby [ft. Clipse] "What Happened to That Boy?"
263. Coldplay "Yellow"
262. Mastodon "Blood & Thunder"
261. Sonic Youth "Incinerate"
260. Of Montreal "Disconnect the Dots"
259. Neko Case "I Wish I Was the Moon"
258. Rachel Stevens "Some Girls"
257. The Flaming Lips "Fight Test"
256. M83 "Kim & Jessie"
255. At the Drive-In "One Armed Scissor"
254. Radiohead "Reckoner"
253. Caribou "Melody Day"
252. Bright Eyes "The Calendar Hung Itself"
251. Eminem "Without Me"
250. The Thermals "A Pillar of Salt"
249. Amadou & Mariam "Sabali"
248. Liars "Plaster Casts of Everything"
247. Broadcast "Pendulum"
246. Lupe Fiasco "Kick Push"
245. Girls Aloud "Biology"
244. The Hives "Hate to Say I Told You So"
243. Fischerspooner "Emerge"
242. Dirty Projectors "Rise Above"
241. Les Savy Fav "The Sweat Descends"
240. Clipse "Zen"
239. The Dismemberment Plan "Face of the Earth"
238. Estelle [ft. Kanye West] "American Boy"
237. Cut Copy "Out There on the Ice"
236. Elliott Smith "A Distorted Reality Is Now a Necessity to Be Free" [7" version]
235. Sally Shapiro "I'll Be by Your Side"
234. Electric Six "Danger! High Voltage!"
233. Air "Playground Love"
232. Destiny's Child "Jumpin' Jumpin'"
231. Jarvis Cocker "Running the World"
230. The Mountain Goats "Best Ever Death Metal Band in Denton"
229. Joanna Newsom "Sprout and the Bean"
228. Phoenix "1901"
227. Björk "Pagan Poetry"
226. Le Tigre "Deceptacon (DFA Remix)"
225. Dntel [ft. Ben Gibbard] "(This Is) The Dream of Evan and Chan"
224. The National "Abel"
223. Beach House "Apple Orchard"
222. Three 6 Mafia "Sippin' on Some Syrup"
221. Fuck Buttons "Sweet Love for Planet Earth"
220. Ekkehard Ehlers "Plays John Cassavettes, Pt. 2"
219. Lil Mama "Lip Gloss"
218. Bloc Party "Banquet"
217. Yeasayer "2080"
216. Sleater-Kinney "Jumpers"
215. M.I.A. "Bucky Done Gun"
214. Freeway [ft. Jay-Z and Beanie Sigel] "What We Do"
213. Yeah Yeah Yeahs "Y Control"
212. The Beta Band "Squares"
211. Ted Leo and the Pharmacists "Timorous Me"
210. Cat Power "Lived in Bars"
209. The Clientele "Since K Got Over Me"
208. Kylie Minogue "Love at First Sight"
207. Outkast [ft. Killer Mike] "The Whole World"
206. Bat for Lashes "Daniel"
205. Lily Allen "Smile"
204. Spoon "Everything Hits at Once"
203. Ricardo Villalobos "Fizheuer Zieheuer"
202. Belle and Sebastian "I'm Waking Up to Us"
201. The New Pornographers "The Laws Have Changed"
200. Beck "Lost Cause"
199. Portishead "The Rip"
198. Vitalic "La Rock 01"
197. Joanna Newsom "Peach, Plum, Pear"
196. No Age "Teen Creeps"
195. Love Is All "Make Out Fall Out Make Up"
194. David Banner "Cadillac on 22's"
193. Twista [ft. Kanye West and Jamie Foxx] "Slow Jamz"
192. Pulp "Sunrise"
191. Vampire Weekend "Oxford Comma"
190. Panjabi MC [ft. Jay-Z] "Mundian to Bach Ké (Beware of the Boys)"
189. The Tough Alliance "Silly Crimes"
188. Jens Lekman "Black Cab"
187. Booka Shade "Mandarine Girl"
186. Fugazi "Cashout"
185. Dead Prez "Hip-Hop"
184. Queens of the Stone Age "No One Knows"
183. Beyoncé "Irreplaceable"
182. Yo La Tengo "Our Way to Fall"
181. Morrissey "The First of the Gang to Die"
180. Gwen Stefani "Hollaback Girl"
179. Bon Iver "Skinny Love"
178. Air "Cherry Blossom Girl"
177. Eminem "The Real Slim Shady"
176. Xiu Xiu "I Luv the Valley OH!"
175. Usher [ft. Lil Jon and Ludacris] "Yeah"
174. Los Campesinos! "You! Me! Dancing!"
173. M.O.P. "Ante Up"
172. Shellac "Prayer to God"
171. Talib Kweli [ft. Mos Def, Jay-Z, Kanye West, and Busta Rhymes] "Get By (Remix)"
170. Guillemots "Trains to Brazil"
169. Ludacris "Southern Hospitality"
168. Of Montreal "The Past Is a Grotesque Animal"
167. Liars "The Other Side of Mt. Heart Attack"
166. Gui Boratto "Beautiful Life"
165. Jimmy Eat World "The Middle"
164. Broadcast "Come on Let's Go"
163. Girl Talk "Smash Your Head"
162. Grizzly Bear "Two Weeks"
161. Christian Falk [ft. Robyn and Ola Salo] "Dream On"
160. 50 Cent "In Da Club"
159. Cat Power "I Don't Blame You"
158. Art Brut "Formed a Band"
157. Kanye West [ft. Lupe Fiasco] "Touch the Sky"
156. The Pipettes "Pull Shapes"
155. Coldplay "Clocks"
154. Sufjan Stevens "Casimir Pulaski Day"
153. Luomo "Tessio"
152. Life Without Buildings "The Leanover"
151. Santogold "L.E.S. Artistes"
150. Junior Senior "Move Your Feet"
149. Dan Deacon "The Crystal Cat"
148. Air France "Collapsing at Your Doorstep"
147. Wilco "Poor Places"
146. Fennesz "Caecilia"
145. Broken Social Scene "Cause = Time"
144. Justice vs. Simian "We Are Your Friends"
143. Feist "1234"
142. The Flaming Lips "Do You Realize??"
141. Britney Spears "Toxic"
140. Interpol "NYC"
139. Daft Punk "Harder, Better, Faster, Stronger"
138. D'Angelo "Untitled (How Does It Feel?)"
137. Ladytron "Destroy Everything You Touch"
136. Ghostface Killah "Shakey Dog"
135. The Strokes "The Modern Age" [EP version]
134. Clipse "Trill"
133. Belle and Sebastian "Your Cover's Blown"
132. Panda Bear "Comfy in Nautica"
131. Destiny's Child "Say My Name"
130. Spoon "The Underdog"
129. Andrew W.K. "Party Hard"
128. The Mountain Goats "No Children"
127. Ciara [ft. Ludacris] "Oh"
126. Califone "The Orchids"
125. The Field "Over the Ice"
124. Ted Leo and the Pharmacists "Where Have All the Rude Boys Gone?"
123. Kanye West "Jesus Walks"
122. Cam'ron [ft. Juelz Santana, Freekey Zekey, and Toya] "Hey Ma"
121. Johnny Boy "You Are the Generation That Bought More Shoes and You Get What You Deserve"
120. Phoenix "If I Ever Feel Better"
119. T.I. "Rubber Band Man"
118. Camera Obscura "Lloyd, I'm Ready to Be Heartbroken"
117. Animal Collective "Leaf House"
116. The White Stripes "Dead Leaves and the Dirty Ground"
115. Dirty Projectors "Stillness Is the Move"
114. !!! "Me and Giuliani Down By the Schoolyard (A True Story)"
113. Kelis "Milkshake"
112. Lindstrøm "I Feel Space"
111. Aaliyah "We Need a Resolution"
110. Dizzee Rascal "Fix Up Look Sharp"
109. Grizzly Bear "Knife"
108. The Hold Steady "The Swish"
107. M83 "Don't Save Us From the Flames"
106. The Mae Shi "Run to Your Grave"
105. Grinderman "No Pussy Blues"
104. Eminem "Lose Yourself"
103. Feist "Mushaboom"
102. Cut Copy "Hearts on Fire"
101. Jürgen Paape "So Weit Wie Noch Nie"

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

Röyksopp with Robyn - The Girl And The Robot is the best song on which Robyn sings imo. Released this year. Top 20?

Re: pitchfork top 500 songs and top 200 albums of the decade

They were big on Konichiwa so I wouldn't be surprised to see that.

Re: Looks Like...

I went through the Pitchfork 500 quickly and here are the songs from this decade that were not in the 500-21
Daft Punk – One More Time
Radiohead – Idioteque
Outkast – B.O.B.
Missy Elliott – Get Ur Freak On
Osymyso – Intro-Inspection
The Knife – Heartbeats
LCD Soundystem – Lossing My Edge
The Rapture – House of Jealous Lovers
My Morning Jacket – The Way That He Sings
Lightning Bolt – Ride the Sky
The Decemberists – Here I Dreamt I Was an Architect
Radiohead – Life in a Glasshouse
Deerhoof – This Magnificent Bird Will Rise
Outkast – Hey Ya
Kanye West – Through The Wire
R. Kelly – Ignition (Remix)
Beyonce – Crazy In Love
Gnarls Barkley – Crazy
Yeah Yeah Yeahs – Maps
The Walkmen – The Rat
M83 – Don’t Save Us from the Flames
Annie – Heartbeat
Boris – Farewell
The Go! Team – The Power Is On
Arcade Fire – Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)
Love Is All – Busy Doing Nothing
Black Dice – Cone Toaster


And the top songs from the 2000-2004 singles list that are not included
1. Outkast- B.O.B.
2. Outkast- Hey Ya!
3. LCD Soundsystem – Losing my Edge
4. Missy Elliott – Get Ur Freak On
6. Annie – Heartbeat
7. Beyonce – Crazy in Love
9. The Rapture – House of Jealous Lovers
10. Yeah Yeah Yeahs – Maps
12. R. Kelly – Ignition (remix)


From 2005-2008 singles/ songs lists the only top 5 singles that are not included yet are
2007
1. LCD Soundsystem – All my Friends
4. M.I.A. - Paper Planes (remix)

2008
01: Hercules and Love Affair- Blind
05: M83- Kim & Jessie

Re: Looks Like...

"Kim & Jessie" is already on the list, isn't it? It's #256.

Re: Looks Like...

My prediction, jus for fun:

1. OutKast - B.O.B. (Bombs Over Baghdad)
2. LCD Soundsystem - All My Friends
3. M.I.A. - Paper Planes
4. Gnarls Barkley - Crazy
5. Hercules and Love Affair - Blind
6. Missy Elliott - Get Ur Freak On
7. Beyonce - Crazy in Love
8. Annie - Heartbeat
9. Radiohead - Idioteque
10. LCD Soundsystem - Losing My Edge
11. Johnny Cash - Hurt
12. Arcade Fire – Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)
13. OutKast - Hey Ya!
14. The Knife - Heartbeats
15. MGMT - Kids
16. Animal Collective - My Girls
17. Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Maps
18. Eminem feat. Dido - Stan
19. R. Kelly - Ignition (Remix)
20. The Rapture - House of Jealous Lovers

"Hurt" may well not make it, this is purely a gut instinct. Same deal with "Stan", though it not making it while "Without Me" makes it is just, well, odd.

If I'm right, the most shocking omissions would be:

The Walkmen - The Rat (Still think this might come in #20 and knock out The Rapture)

Joanna Newsom - Emily (2 from Milk-Eyed and 0 from Ys? Shocking)

Jay-Z - 99 Problems (with 3 songs in the Top 100, I guess that would be considered enough)

LCD Soundsystem - Yeah! (again, 3 in the Top 100)

Wilco - I Am Trying to Break Your Heart (only 2 from YHF, I'm thinking. I think they got the right 2, though this is often name-checked)

The Strokes – Last Nite and Hard to Explain (I think Is This It only lands 2 on, though either of these appearing would not surprise me)

Amy Winehouse - Rehab (don't think she's a P-fork favorite)

Daft Punk - One More Time (eclipsed by the far superior Digital Love)

Re: Looks Like...

1. LCD Soundsystem - All My Friends
2. OutKast - B.O.B
3. OutKast - Hey Ya!
4. Gnarls Barkley - Crazy
5. Hercules and Love Affair - Blind
6. M.I.A - Paper Planes
7. Beyonce - Crazy in Love
8. Annie - Heartbeat
9. LCD Soundsystem - Losing My Edge
10. Missy Elliot - Get Ur Freak On
11. Animal Collective - My Girls
12. Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Maps
13. Radiohead - Idioteque
14. Jay Z - 99 Problems
15. MGMT - Kids
16. The Rapture - House of Jealous Lovers
17. Eminem - Stan
18. LCD Soundsystem - Yeah!
19. R. Kelley - Ignition (Remix)
20. Arcade Fire - Neighborhood #1

This is my final prediction, with just under 2 hours untill unveiling. I'm going to call that LCDSS and Jigga do indeed put 4 songs into the T100. Pitchfork clearly loves both artists. Also, sonofsamiam, I think calling Hey Ya for anything other than T10 is a losing proposition.

Re: Looks Like...

The Strokes will NOT make the top 20. Pitchfork already said that Someday was the highest ranking Strokes song.

I was disappointed to see Bro's so low. I really thought that would be in the top 10.

I still stand my pick of All My Friends for number one, though.

Re: Looks Like...

Harold Wexler
"Kim & Jessie" is already on the list, isn't it? It's #256.


Ya you're right it is on the list.
I just did the list fast.

edit
It's up

Re: Looks Like...

I'd be thrilled if Annie's "Heartbeat" landed at number 8, as both of you predict. I'm happy enough that it's in the top 20, but a top 10 place would be excellent.

Re: Looks Like...

1. OutKast -B.O.B.
2. LCD Soundsystem - All My Friends
3. M.I.A. [ft. Bun B and Rich Boy] - Paper Planes (Diplo Remix)
4. Beyoncé [ft. Jay-Z] - Crazy in Love
5. Daft Punk - One More Time
6. Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Maps
7.Missy Elliott - Get Ur Freak On
8. Radiohead - Idioteque
9. Animal Collective - My Girls
10. Arcade Fire - Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)
11. Gnarls Barkley - Crazy
12. OutKast - Hey Ya!
13. LCD Soundsystem - Losing My Edge
14. Jay-Z - 99 Problems
15. The Knife - Heartbeats
16. The Rapture - House of Jealous Lovers
17. Annie - Heartbeat
18. Hercules and Love Affair - Blind
19. R. Kelly - Ignition (Remix)
20. The Walkmen - The Rat

edit
Other than the semi-high placement of Beyonce and low placement of Hey Ya! it is not that suprising.

Re: Looks Like...

brose
1. OutKast -B.O.B.
2. LCD Soundsystem - All My Friends
3. M.I.A. [ft. Bun B and Rich Boy] - Paper Planes (Diplo Remix)
4. Beyoncé [ft. Jay-Z] - Crazy in Love
5. Daft Punk - One More Time
6. Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Maps
7.Missy Elliott - Get Ur Freak On
8. Radiohead - Idioteque
9. Animal Collective - My Girls
10. Arcade Fire - Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)
11. Gnarls Barkley - Crazy
12. OutKast - Hey Ya!
13. LCD Soundsystem - Losing My Edge
14. Jay-Z - 99 Problems
15. The Knife - Heartbeats
16. The Rapture - House of Jealous Lovers
17. Annie - Heartbeat
18. Hercules and Love Affair - Blind
19. R. Kelly - Ignition (Remix)
20. The Walkmen - The Rat

edit
Other than the semi-high placement of Beyonce and low placement of Hey Ya! it is not that suprising.


i'm pretty surprised by beyonce, but hey... great list

Re: Looks Like...

So my friend and I had a bet, me on All My Friends, him on Hey Ya. Got there! As said other than Beyonce's high placing and Hey Ya not making T10, the list isn't shocking, and I feel as though the T3 is excellent.

When I saw Neighborhood #1 at 10, I jumped out of my seat and announced "All hail Funeral! Greatest record of the 00s!". Then when I scrolled down to 8th pitchfork sent me back to reality. How lame would it be if they ddi B.O.B/Kid A again? Although I do have to say, BOB is a worthy champion. Anyway, after seeing the results of this list, NEW PREDICTION

1. Radiohead - Kid A
2. Arcade Fire - Funeral
3. Animal Collective - Merriweather Post Pavillion
4. Jay Z - The Blueprint
5. Sufjan Stevens - Illinois
6. The Knife - Silet Shout
7. OutKast - Stankonia
8. Panda Bear - Person Pitch
9. LCD Soundsystem - Sound of Silver
10. Interpol - Turn on the Bright Lights

Re: Looks Like...

Does anyone else think Idioteque is too high? It's a solid song, but I'm not sure that I would put it in my top 10 for the year let alone the decade.

Re: Looks Like...

i just realized "Stan" wasn't on the list.... and this makes me sad.

also, i agree with ^^^ i love idiotesque, definitely up there, maybe even top 20... but i like the national anthem better

Re: Looks Like...

SR
So my friend and I had a bet, me on All My Friends, him on Hey Ya. Got there! As said other than Beyonce's high placing and Hey Ya not making T10, the list isn't shocking, and I feel as though the T3 is excellent.

When I saw Neighborhood #1 at 10, I jumped out of my seat and announced "All hail Funeral! Greatest record of the 00s!". Then when I scrolled down to 8th pitchfork sent me back to reality. How lame would it be if they ddi B.O.B/Kid A again? Although I do have to say, BOB is a worthy champion. Anyway, after seeing the results of this list, NEW PREDICTION

1. Radiohead - Kid A
2. Arcade Fire - Funeral
3. Animal Collective - Merriweather Post Pavillion
4. Jay Z - The Blueprint
5. Sufjan Stevens - Illinois
6. The Knife - Silet Shout
7. OutKast - Stankonia
8. Panda Bear - Person Pitch
9. LCD Soundsystem - Sound of Silver
10. Interpol - Turn on the Bright Lights


i have the oddest feeling like this will pretty much be exactly it. though personally, i like return to cookie mountain better than silent shout and YHF better than turn on the bright lights, but w/e

Re: Looks Like...

Chris
Does anyone else think Idioteque is too high? It's a solid song, but I'm not sure that I would put it in my top 10 for the year.


Hell, I don't thing it's the best song off Kid A.

Re: Looks Like...

SR
When I saw Neighborhood #1 at 10, I jumped out of my seat and announced "All hail Funeral! Greatest record of the 00s!". Then when I scrolled down to 8th pitchfork sent me back to reality.


I thought the exact same thing well without the jumping.

Re: Looks Like...

DC
Chris
Does anyone else think Idioteque is too high? It's a solid song, but I'm not sure that I would put it in my top 10 for the year.


Hell, I don't thing it's the best song off Kid A.


For me Idioteque is the best song Radiohead did in the 00s (and depending on which day you ask, maybe the best Radiohead song ever)

Top50 song ever for me (as are B.O.B. and All My Friends)

I would not pick Neighborhood 1 and Rebellions Lies as the 2 best song from Funeral but it is great to see the band so high anyway (but Walk Up is the best song from the album and should be there instead)

Re: Looks Like...

I am disappointed in a number of songs that didn't make the list or where I felt the placement was too low. With those that didn't make the list, some I felt were excluded because they didn't wan to put too many songs by the same artist on the list - which I think partly misses the point, because aren't they after all evaluating simply the best songs of the decade, period, regardless of politics? Some just didn't make the list because it's pitchfork, so no matter how much I think some U2 or "Viva La Vida" or something unhip should at least be in the top FIVE HUNDRED songs of the decade, I understand the source and had a feeling they wouldn't be there at all.

But....

That being said, I feel like the the top 10 is pretty solid. Even the ranking was well done (I didn't think the ranking was well done everywhere, that's for sure..."Two Weeks" was too low, for one)....the one thing I maybe would have changed - "Crazy In Love" should be switched with "Hey Ya" as the decade's best pop single, or maybe Gnarls Barkley "Crazy" (I could live with either of those replacing "Get Your Freak On" too but I understand the power that song has over critics....) Besides that though, solid top 10. Glad to see "Neighborhoods #1."

Re: Looks Like...

My two cents...

#19. "Ignition (Remix)"
Remember when R. Kelly was facing all those child molestation charges, and he responds by coming out with an album called "Chocolate Factory" and the big single off that is this one? Balls, man. Big brass ones. I don't know why I love this song as much as I do, but I'm very happy to see it as high as it is.

#16. "House of Jealous Lovers"
The critics seem to love this song, and my feelings toward it ebb and flow. Literally two days ago, I was cranking it up and singing along in my car. Today I can't stand to think I was doing that. At 16, it's too high, but it's not TOO high.

#12. "Hey Ya!"
At 12, it's WAY too low. This should definitely be top ten, maybe even top five.

#11. "Crazy"
See my comments for "Hey Ya!"

#10. "Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)"
I'm convinced that "Rebellion (Lies)" is the better track, but I'm not going to complain with a track from Funeral getting to the #10 spot. Besides, even though it's not my favorite track off the album, it still kicks ass.

#8. "Idioteque"
GOD DAMN IT! I just cannot understand why this fucking song gets so much love. Or even why Kid A gets so much love. I've listened to that album so many times, and there is nothing worth listening to after "Optimistic." Pitchfork even falls all over itself calling the album "miraculous." Jesus Christ, get off your knees and take Radiohead's... (the rest of this comment contains offensive language, incitements to violence, and rubber novelty poop and has therefore been deleted)

#4. "Crazy in Love"
Pretty good pop song, granted. But the fourth best of the decade? This just confirms my belief that this has been a REALLY weak decade.

#3. "Paper Planes (Diplo Remix)"
For my own sake, can I just say that it's the album version of this song and not some remix? If so, then I'll agree with it. Brilliant track.

#1. "B.O.B."
I remember when "Ms. Jackson" was blowing up the airwaves thinking, "Yeah, it's good, but why the hell isn't 'B.O.B.' getting this kind of love?" I'm a little surprised to see it at #1, but I'm certainly not disappointed.

Re: Looks Like...

Matt Schroeder

#10. "Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)"
I'm convinced that "Rebellion (Lies)" is the better track, but I'm not going to complain with a track from Funeral getting to the #10 spot. Besides, even though it's not my favorite track off the album, it still kicks ass.


yes.

Re: Looks Like...

Strange, I can't see the results yet on my computer. I've tried deleting cookies, and still nothing!

I was hoping Annie could crack the top 10, but what the heck. I'm happy that "Maps" did, and "All My Friends" at number 2 is certainly a lofty position!

I simply cannot fathom the love for Beyonce or R. Kelly, though. I hated those songs the first time I heard them, and I hate them just as much now. In fact, "Crazy in Love" pollutes my bottom 100 songs list.

Re: Looks Like...

Nassim
I would not pick Neighborhood 1 and Rebellions Lies as the 2 best song from Funeral but it is great to see the band so high anyway (but Walk Up is the best song from the album and should be there instead)


"Rebellion (Lies)" is my favorite, but I agree on "Wake Up" and I also love "Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)." That song just ebbs and flows, and builds and builds and BUILDS, in such an anthemic way, until it ends with that final crashing chord ... then a few seconds of sustain ... then ANOTHER crash. FUNERAL was playing while I was in a Borders the other night, and even though I had finished my business and was actually in kind of a rush to get home, when "Power Out" came on I simply couldn't leave until it was over. It would have felt ... disrespectful.

By the way, has everyone seen the amazing trailer for Spike Jonze's adaptation of WHERE THE WILD THINGS ARE that uses "Wake Up" as its backing music? Oh, man.

Re: Looks Like...

So, I was wrong about:

"Hurt" -- I find it strange "The Man Comes Around" made it and this didn't. Maybe it'll top the videos list to make up for it?

"Stan" -- How "The Real Slim Shady" and "Without Me" made it and this did not is baffling. Dated self-mythology trumps storytelling and honest emotion, I suppose.

"Kids" -- just shocked about this, guess they're just not MGMT fans. (Neither am I, so I'm not that sad about it.)

Glad "99 Problems" made it so high. "One More Time" at #5 is shocking, though I do love Daft Punk. That high is still a surprise though. I don't think I get the amount of acclaim "The Rat" gets -- good song, but #20 of the decade?

And I go for "The National Anthem" over "Idioteque" any day of the week, but that's just a taste thing.



Still, gonna give myself slight props for picking the Top 3.

Re: Looks Like...

Calling the top 3 was really sick. The only prediction I saw that was better was one on metacritic where they got 19 songs, missing only Neighborhood #1 for Emily.

Biggest surprise for me was loading the page and seeing Walkmen at 20th instead of Stan. In hindsight, Kids was a bad call. Pitchfork has expressed their dislike for MGMT in the past.

Re: Looks Like...

Maybe the fork is with me on Eminem. I think his serious stuff is only acclaimed because it's him... nobody thought he had it in him even if it isn't all that great. His forte is being obnoxious, having fun and creating club anthems... and they're pretty good songs.

Re: Looks Like...

sonofsamiam
So, I was wrong about:

"Hurt" -- I find it strange "The Man Comes Around" made it and this didn't. Maybe it'll top the videos list to make up for it?

I don't think I get the amount of acclaim "The Rat" gets -- good song, but #20 of the decade?

Still, gonna give myself slight props for picking the Top 3.


I feel there are very few covers in the list which might explain the omission of "Hurt". "The Man Comes Around" might also be seen as his "swan song". And my neck hair did stand up once I listened to it...

"The Rat" is a "Fred" song, it's all about the same old "tension" - "release tension" thing. They are in the business of tension delivery, The Walkmen. And sometimes such a song "smokes".

1 2