Put a Pin on the Map View my Forum Guestmap
Free Guestmaps by Bravenet.com

The Old Acclaimed Music Forum

Go to the NEW FORUM

Music, music, music...
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
You're No Ten

If you can vote one album off the big top ten of all time what would it be and what album would you replace it with?

Re: You're No Ten

I'd probably kick off Never Mind the Bullocks and put Loveless on there. For the most part, I like all the albums in the top 10, but Sex Pistols doesn't really have as considerable an impact on me as the others--despite the fact that sheer "impact" is what it's all about, hehe.

Re: You're No Ten

Out: Sgt. Pepper
In: OK Computer

(If I had a second pick, I'd replace Pet Sounds with Automatic for the People.)

Re: You're No Ten

Easy choice:

Kicked Off: Sex Pistols - Never Mind The Bollocks
Replacement: Bob Dylan - Highway 61 Revisited (it deserves to be higher though)

Re: You're No Ten

Out: Nevermind
In: Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain

Re: You're No Ten

Out: Sex Pistols
In: Remain In Light from the Talking Heads

Second pick out: Nevermind
In: Murmur from R.E.M.

Re: You're No Ten

Out: Sex Pistols "Never Mind the Bollocks..."
In: Jimi Hendrix Experience "Are You Experienced?"

Second Pick Out: The Rolling Stones "Exile on Main Street"
In: Pink Floyd "Dark Side of the Moon"

I really think that Sex Pistols album isn't that great outside of a track or two. I'd much rather hear any Clash or Ramones album.

Though I've now come to appreciate the Stones album a bit, I much prefer STICKY FINGERS to that one.

Re: You're No Ten

I can justify What's Going On, London Calling and Never Mind the Bullocks as important for their genres and music in general but I can't justify Exile On Main Street. That's no ten.

Re: You're No Ten

Guess I'd have to kick out Nevermind for Who's Next

Re: You're No Ten

Out: Never Mind The Bollocks
In: OK Computer

And before too long, it will be.

Re: You're No Ten

Exile on Main Street for Crooked Rain Crooked Rain

I Still love Exile though.

Re: You're No Ten

out : Bollocks
in : Born to Run

or a Beatles switch

out : Seargent P
in : White album

Re: You're No Ten

Out: Sex Pistols
In: OK Computer

Re: You're No Ten

Out: Nevermind
In: White Album

Re: You're No Ten

Out: Sgt. Pepper
In: The Great Rock'n'Roll Swindle

Re: You're No Ten

If I could replace albums, I'd replace them with something similar... so here it goes.

1. Pet Sounds- Stays
2. Revolver- Stays
3. Nevermind- Stays
4. VU +Nico- Stays
5. Sgt. Peppers- Replaced with Rubber Soul
6. Blonde on Blonde- Replaced with Highway 61
7. Exile on Main Street- Replaced with Television: Marquee Moon
8. What's Going On- Replaced with Stevie Wonder: Songs in the Key of Life
9. Never Mind the Bullocks- Replaced with Stooges: Funhouse
10. Clash- London Calling- Stays

Re: You're No Ten

Marquee Moon is similar to Exile On Main St.?

=O

Re: You're No Ten

Not really. I was just looking at guitar based rock and roll and I couldn't justify keeping Exile in the top 10.