See, I told you these lists were coming out too quick. Burial's Untrue came out this week and guess what? It's the #1 album on Metacritic. It's a great album by the way.
My pet peeve are albums and movies that come out late in the year. Postpone it to January and see how the longevity of the acclaim lasts. When you release something in December you're asking to be put on everyone's year end list. It's a cop out.