Put a Pin on the Map View my Forum Guestmap
Free Guestmaps by Bravenet.com

The Old Acclaimed Music Forum

Go to the NEW FORUM

Music, music, music...
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

The 50 Best Scottish Bands Of All Time (as voted for by the public) are as follows:

1 Belle & Sebastian
2 Travis
3 Idlewild
4 Wet Wet Wet
5 Sensational Alex Harvey Band
6 Simple Minds
7 Teenage Fanclub
8 Bay City Rollers
9 Primal Scream
10 The Proclaimers
11 Texas
12 Mull historical society
13 Big country
14 Snow Patrol
15 Franz Ferdinand
16 Bis
17 Deacon Blue
18 Fish
19 Jesus and Mary Chain
20 Mogwai
21 Runrig
22 Trash Can Sinatras
23 Del Amitri
24 Orange Juice
25 Nazareth
26 Beta Band
27 Biffy Clyro
28 Altered Images
29 Aztec Camera
30 Eddi Reader
31 Goodbye Mr Mackenzie
32 Fire Engines
33 Delgados
34 Arab strap
35 Vaselines
36 Associates
37 The Pastels
38 Eurythmics
39 Aereogramme
40 Blue Nile
41 Boards of Canada
42 Rezillos
43 Incredible string band
44 Cocteau twins
45 Dogs Die in Hot Cars
46 Spare Snare
47 Average White Band
48 Lulu
49 Skids
50 Shamen

Re: List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

Wet Wet Wet at #4 while there's no Camera Obscura in this list...?

Re: List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

That's bollocks - Teenage Fanclub for #1

Re: List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

Wow! Scottland has produced some great pop music.

Re: List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

Indeed it is a travesty that there's no Camera Obscura. Surprising to see FF so low. And Snow Patrol are Northern Irish

Re: List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

Correct, MightyMadMax. Although formed in Dundee, Scotland, the band members are from Bangor and Belfast:

http://www.snowpatrol.com/band/faq.aspx#5

Wet Wet Wet on #4 and Boards on #41, also seems a bit awkward to me.

Re: List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

Glad to see Runrig included. Their best work may have been a while ago, but Heartland is an album I keep returning to (and without them there would hardly be any Big Country).

Re: List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

Based on my album ratings, this is my personal Scottish top 10:

1. Belle and Sebastian
2. Cocteau Twins
3. The Waterboys
4. Teenage Fanclub
5. Travis
6. Simple Minds
7. Primal Scream
8. Franz Ferdinand
9. The Blue Nile
10. Boards Of Canada

NB: Never heard anything from Camera Obscura ... yet.

Re: List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

How is Orange Juice #24? That's crazy and also sad that such a great band isn't even respected in their own country... especially since the poll shows that they weren't exclusively voting for new acts.

Re: List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

1 Belle & Sebastian
2 Travis
3 Idlewild
4 Wet Wet Wet

Worst top 4 ever.

Re: List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

Where the hell is Dawn of the Replicants???? That list is AWFUL!

Re: List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

Belle and Sebastian @ #1 is awesome but the Cocteaus and the Mary Chain are ranked way too low. I knew Snow Patrol were Irish. Poeple kept insisting they were Scottish so I just went with the crowd and assumed they were Scottish. I'd even put Camera Obscura in my top 5. To me they sound more like the Sundays than Belle and Sebastian but these days every indie band is trying to sound like Belle and Sebastian. Watch any Target commercial and you'll see what I'm talking about. Since B&S is #1 it's only logical to have their biggest influences, Orange Juice and the Vaselines in the top 10 as well.

Re: List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

For me it's:

1. Eurythmics








Everyone else.

Re: List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

This is how I’d rank them:

1 Delgados – one of the most undervalued bands of the past ten years.
2 Orange Juice
3 Blue Nile
4 Aztec Camera
5 Boards of Canada
6 Mogwai
7 Vaselines
8 Big country
9 Cocteau twins
10 Arab strap
11 Belle & Sebastian
12 Teenage Fanclub
13 The Pastels
14 Primal Scream
15 Jesus and Mary Chain3


I think Deacon Blue may well be the worst band of all time.

Re: List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

That's pretty close to how I'd rank them too. Orange Juice would be #1 and the Delgados would be pushed down a few spots.

Re: List's Greatest Scottish Bands of All Time

Here's my ranking
1. Cocteau Twins
2. Belle and Sebastian
3. Jesus and Mary Chain
4. Trashcan Sinatras
5. Camera Obscura
6. Mull Historical Society
7. Primal Scream
8. Orange Juice
9. the Vaselines
10. the Gentle Waves