Put a Pin on the Map View my Forum Guestmap
Free Guestmaps by Bravenet.com

The Old Acclaimed Music Forum

Go to the NEW FORUM

Music, music, music...
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
UMT2:

Final 2nd round matchup, 3 weeks until championship round... vote for your winners, results posted tomorrow:
#1 The Beastie Boys vs. #8 The Cult
#5 Eric B. & Rakim vs. #4 Nick Cave
#3 Sonic Youth vs. #6 Lenny Kravitz
#7 Huey Lewis & The News vs. #2 Depeche Mode
#1 Nirvana vs. #8 Phil Collins
#5 Motley Crue vs. #4 NWA
#3 Janet Jackson vs. #6 Faith No More
#10 Soft Cell vs. #2 The Replacements

Re: UMT2:

#1 The Beastie Boys
#4 Nick Cave
#3 Sonic Youth
#2 Depeche Mode
#1 Nirvana
#4 NWA
#3 Janet Jackson
#10 Soft Cell

Re: UMT2: 2nd round / #15

Beasties - Though I would have taken The Cult in 3 other matchups, I have really enjoyed the New B Boys album after the first couple of listens...
Eric B. & Rakim
Sonic Youth - I did struggle with this, I do like alot of what Lenny has done.
DM - I have a soft spot for Huey, just not against Depeche
Nirvana - I think if Phil was in this he might vote for Nirvana!!!
Crue - I do not know how to put the umalat or whatever that thing is over the u...
Faith No More - Still today known for getting clubs to play Epic and then doing the flopping fish at the end of the video on the dancefloor!!!
The Replacements - Say Hello Wave Goodbye is a great, great song, but it would not even come close to a list of the top 10 Replacements tunes...

Re: UMT2:

#1 The Beastie Boys
#4 Nick Cave
#3 Sonic Youth
#2 Depeche Mode
#1 Nirvana
pass
#3 Janet Jackson
#10 Soft Cell

Re: UMT2:

pass
#4 Nick Cave
pass
pass
#1 Nirvana
#4 NWA
#3 Janet Jackson
pass

Re: UMT2:

#1 The Beastie Boys
#5 Eric B. & Rakim (VERY tough, a case of where a short sharp peak beats a long career of smaller peaks...barely)
#3 Sonic Youth
#2 Depeche Mode
#1 Nirvana
#4 NWA
#3 Janet Jackson (Also VERY VERY tough, and extremely hard to compare...but Janet was more consistent for longer)
#2 The Replacements

Aside from the 2 I pointed out, every other matchup was a no-brainer today.

Re: UMT2:

#1 The Beastie Boys : tied for favorite band ever
#5 Eric B. & Rakim
#3 Sonic Youth
#2 Depeche Mode
#1 Nirvana
#4 NWA (Mötley Crüe... easy to type with a French keyboard, I would call that a trema more than an umlaut)
#6 Faith No More
#2 The Replacements (if you ask me what is the best album I have discovered through AM Forum polls, Let it Be is always one of the first that comes to mind)

Re: UMT2:

#1 The Beastie Boys: Close call here, but I own a few Beasties CDs but nothing by The Cult despite being intrigued by them.
Pass (Don't know enough of either, really.)
#6 Lenny Kravitz: For his first 3 albums.
#2 Depeche Mode: I've been Depeching a lot lately. They're close to my top 10.
#1 Nirvana: Phil gets undue hate, but Nirvana has this easily.
#5 Mötley Crüe: Headbanging delight! By the way, it's Alt+148 for ö and Alt+0252 for ü.
#3 Janet Jackson: I like Faith No More, but Janet is vital for me.
#10 Soft Cell: Very underrated synth pop filth at its finest.

Re: UMT2:

Beastie Boys
Eric B. and Rakim
Sonic Youth
Depeche Mode
Nirvana
NWA
Pass
The Replacements

Re: UMT2:

Sorry Moonbeam, but IMO these 80s second round brackets have been really poor quality.

#1 The Beastie Boys
#4 Nick Cave
#3 Sonic Youth
#2 Depeche Mode
#1 Nirvana
#4 NWA
#3 Janet Jackson
#2 The Replacements

Re: UMT2:

The Cult
Nick Cave
Sonic Youth
Depeche Mode
Nirvana
NWA
Janet Jackson
The Replacements

Re: UMT2:

#1 The Beastie Boys
#4 Nick Cave
#3 Sonic Youth
#2 Depeche Mode
#1 Nirvana
#4 NWA
#3 Ms. Jackson - 'cause I'm nasty
#2 The Replacements

Thanks!

Re: UMT2:

#1 The Beastie Boys
#4 Nick Cave
#3 Sonic Youth
#2 Depeche Mode
#8 Phil Collins (Not even very close either)
#4 NWA
#3 Janet Jackson
#2 The Replacements

Re: UMT2:

BEASTIE BOYS (Have not yet heard all of Hot Sauce Committee, but they would have taken this matchup on Paul’s Boutique alone. Hell, they would have taken it on Ill Communication alone.)

ERIC B. & RAKIM (Close!)

SONIC YOUTH (Raw material over shrink-wrapped product.)

DEPECHE MODE (I forget which poster said this last round, but I too go back on forth on whether Depeche Mode is OK or not…they do have some songs I like. But I am positive that Huey Lewis is not OK.)

NIRVANA (Heh.)

N.W.A. (Neither of these acts is my cuppa, really, but I’m very comfortable with my choice.)

FAITH NO MORE (Like a lot of you have already said, these artists are pretty close in my estimation. I went with the one that resonated a bit more with me personally.)

THE REPLACEMENTS

Re: UMT2:

pass
pass
#3 Sonic Youth
#2 Depeche Mode
#1 Nirvana
pass
#3 Janet Jackson
#2 The Replacements

Re: UMT2:

#1 The Beastie Boys
Don't care
#3 Sonic Youth
#2 Depeche Mode (Huey's fun and all, but ...)
#1 Nirvana (I'm voting for the act that I actually never saw live)
#4 NWA (Almost don't care)
#6 Faith No More (This was very close, but "Angel Dust" is an all-time favorite)
#2 The Replacements

Re: UMT2:

#1 The Beastie Boys
#5 Eric B. & Rakim
#3 Sonic Youth
#2 Depeche Mode
#1 Nirvana
#4 NWA
#3 Janet Jackson
#2 The Replacements

Re: UMT2:

#1 The Beastie Boys
#4 Nick Cave
#3 Sonic Youth
#2 Depeche Mode
#1 Nirvana
Easiest vote of the tournament.
#4 NWA
#3 Janet Jackson
#2 The Replacements

Re: UMT2:

Pass
#4 Nick Cave
#3 Sonic Youth
#2 Depeche Mode
#1 Nirvana
PAss
PAss
#2 The Replacements

Re: UMT2:

#1 The Beastie Boys
#4 Nick Cave
#3 Sonic Youth
#2 Depeche Mode
#1 Nirvana
#4 NWA
#6 Faith No More
#2 The Replacements

Re: UMT2:

It's on!

Beastie Boys (in a nail-biter)
Nick Cave (a bit less close, but still tight)
Sonic Youth
Depeche Mode
Nirvana (closest 1 vs. 8 in this round)
Motley Crue (yes, really)
Faith no More
Replacements

Re: UMT2:

#1 The Beastie Boys
#4 Nick Cave- An artist who always has a song on an album that I love but I end up not liking the rest of the album. Still for how long he's been doing it, that's a lot of good songs.
#3 Sonic Youth
#2 Depeche Mode
#1 Nirvana
#4 NWA
#3 Janet Jackson
#2 The Replacements

Re: UMT2:

#1 The Beastie Boys
#4 Nick Cave
#3 Sonic Youth
#2 Depeche Mode
#1 Nirvana
#4 NWA
#6 Faith No More
#2 The Replacements

Re: UMT2:

Schwah
Sorry Moonbeam, but IMO these 80s second round brackets have been really poor quality.


The 60s and 90s have been crap for me. No surprise there!

Re: UMT2:

Nirvana
The only matchup where I really know both well enough (thanks to my mom) to vote.

Re: UMT2:

RESULTS:
The Beastie Boys 87.9% / The Cult 12.1%
Nick Cave 51.5% / Eric B. & Rakim 48.5%
Sonic Youth 70.6% / Lenny Kravitz 29.4%
Nirvana 83.3% / Phil Collins 16.7%
N.W.A. 68.8% / Motley Crue 31.2% (couldn't get Moonbeam's suggestions to work)
Janet Jackson 61.8% / Faith No More 38.2%
The Replacements 79.4% / Soft Cell 20.6%

Re: UMT2:

Not that the outcome is in doubt, but what about Depeche Mode v. Huey Lewis?

Re: UMT2:

schleuse
Not that the outcome is in doubt, but what about Depeche Mode v. Huey Lewis?



How did I miss this... nice catch:
Depeche Mode 74.3% / Huey Lewis & The News 25.7%