Put a Pin on the Map View my Forum Guestmap
Free Guestmaps by Bravenet.com

The Old Acclaimed Music Forum

Go to the NEW FORUM

Music, music, music...
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

Vote for your winners, results posted Monday:
#1 Michael Jackson vs. #16 Richard And Linda Thompson
#8 Def Leppard vs. #9 George Harrison
#5 Paul Simon vs. #12 Squeeze
#4 Rush vs. #13 Bill Withers
#3 Kraftwerk vs. #14 The Gap Band
#6 Kiss vs. #11 The Commodores
#7 Paul McCartney/Wings vs. #10 The B-52’s
#2 The Police vs. #15 The Knack

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

#1 Michael Jackson
#9 George Harrison
#5 Paul Simon
#13 Bill Withers
#14 The Gap Band
#6 Kiss
#7 Paul McCartney/Wings
#2 The Police

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

pass
pass
#5 Paul Simon
#13 Bill Withers
#3 Kraftwerk
pass
pass
#2 The Police

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

#1 Michael Jackson: 18 defeats #16 Richard And Linda Thompson: 6
#8 Def Leppard: 13 defeats #9 George Harrison: 2
#12 Squeeze: 12 defeats #5 Paul Simon: 5
#13 Bill Withers: 11 defeats #4 Rush: 7
#14 The Gap Band: 18 defeats #3 Kraftwerk: 18 (Damn! I actually like Kraftwerk more, but I know they'll win, and Gap Band deserve some love!)
#11 The Commodores: 11 defeats #6 Kiss: 7
#10 The B-52’s: 15 defeats #7 Paul McCartney/Wings: 0
#2 The Police: 13 defeats #15 The Knack: 12

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

#16 Richard And Linda Thompson
#9 George Harrison
#5 Paul Simon
#4 Rush
#3 Kraftwerk
#6 Kiss
#7 Paul McCartney/Wings
#2 The Police

Thanks!

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

#1 Michael Jackson
#9 George Harrison
#5 Paul Simon
Pass
#3 Kraftwerk
#11 The Commodores
#7 Paul McCartney/Wings(hard choice)
#2 The Police

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

Michael Jackson
George Harrison
Paul Simon
Pass
Kraftwerk
Pass
The B-52's
The Police

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

Vote for your winners, results posted Monday:
#1 Michael Jackson
pass
pass
pass
pass
pass
#10 The B-52’s
#2 The Police

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

#1 Michael Jackson
#9 George Harrison - Love Pyromania, loathe Hysteria. But Harrison is much better all around.
#5 Paul Simon - Like Squeeze, but no contest.
#13 Bill Withers - Close call.
#3 Kraftwerk
#11 The Commodores - Remember, KISS is one of the three worst artists of all time.
#7 Paul McCartney/Wings
#2 The Police

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

#1 Michael Jackson
#9 George Harrison
#5 Paul Simon
#4 Rush
#3 Kraftwerk
#11 The Commodores
#7 Paul McCartney/Wings
#2 The Police

Def Leppard and Squeeze had very tough match-ups. I would have liked to vote for both of these groups if they were matched against Kraftwerk or Kiss.

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

Moonbeam
George Harrison: 2


So, you have a bit of a soft spot for Harrison it seems (at least compared to Paul McCartney).

Are any of Harrison's songs with the Beatles tolerable for you?

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

#16 Richard And Linda Thompson
#9 George Harrison
#5 Paul Simon
#4 Rush
#3 Kraftwerk
#6 Kiss
#7 Paul McCartney/Wings
#2 The Police

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

#1 Michael - Not a big MJ fan except for a few songs, still too early to vote against them.

#8 Def Leppard - Still enjoy their early stuff.

#12 SQUEEZE - Great band, Paul's solo stuff is way overrated. "Annie Get You Gun" is waaaaayy better than anything Simon ever did, (At least in my opinion).

#4 RUSH - Darkhorse finalist in a tough bracket???

#14 - The Gap Band - It's all about Skate U in 6th grade throwing grenades to "You Dropped A Bomb On Me"

#6 - Kiss

#10 - The B-52's - Yah Fred Schneider is annoying, but so was 70's version of Paul.

#2 - The PoPo - "My Sherona" was a great song, but this is The Po-Leece we are talking about!!!

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

#16 Richard And Linda Thompson (I do actually prefer MJ, but it's a shame the Thompsons have to leave in the first round and I don't want to see them lose without at least a few votes)
#8 Def Leppard
#5 Paul Simon
#4 Rush
#3 Kraftwerk
#11 The Commodores
#10 The B-52’s
#2 The Police

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

#16 Richard And Linda Thompson (pretty even, but then the whole child molestation thing tipped the scales)
#9 George Harrison (mop top beats hair rock)
#5 Paul Simon
Don't Care
Don't Care
#11 The Commodores
#7 Paul McCartney/Wings (Almost too close to call)
#2 The Police

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

Interweb access is down for me, so I'm doing this on my phone. Hence a comment-free ballot, except to say that my faves today are #12 and #10.

#1 Michael Jackson
Pass
#12 Squeeze
#13 Bill Withers
#3 Kraftwerk
Pass
#10 The B-52's
#2 The Police

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

#1 Michael Jackson (I'm going MJ just because I'm not a big Richard and Linda Thompson fan but remember that you are voting for Ben, Got To Be There and Off the Wall MJ. Weird to see him #1 seed for the 70's)
#9 George Harrison
#5 Paul Simon
#4 Rush (Tough call)
#3 Kraftwerk
#11 The Commodores
#7 Paul McCartney/Wings
#15 The Knack

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

pass
#9 George Harrison
#5 Paul Simon
#4 Rush
#3 Kraftwerk
#11 The Commodores
#7 Paul McCartney/Wings
#2 The Police

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

Do artists show up in multiple decades? I guess Michael Jackson only had two albums in the 80's but I don't think there are many people who wouldn't call him an 80's artist.

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

John
#1 Michael Jackson (I'm going MJ just because I'm not a big Richard and Linda Thompson fan but remember that you are voting for Ben, Got To Be There and Off the Wall MJ. Weird to see him #1 seed for the 70's)
#9 George Harrison
#5 Paul Simon
#4 Rush (Tough call)
#3 Kraftwerk
#11 The Commodores
#7 Paul McCartney/Wings
#15 The Knack



It is there overall body of work, the artists were catagorized by the decade in which they debuted for tournament purposes. Otherwise how many artists would show up in multiple decades if you only voted for their work in the decade in which they were placed in.

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

John
Do artists show up in multiple decades? I guess Michael Jackson only had two albums in the 80's but I don't think there are many people who wouldn't call him an 80's artist.


No.

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

OK, sounds good.

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

Michael Jackson
Def Leppard
Paul Simon
Rush
Kraftwerk
Kiss
Paul McCarney/Wings
Police (give the legends a boost and let the one-hit wonders go)

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

Michael Jackson
Def Leppard
Paul Simon
Rush
Kraftwerk
Kiss
The B-52s
The Police

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

#1 Michael Jackson
#9 George Harrison
#12 Squeeze
I don't find Paul Simon's solo work that strong.
pass
pass
pass
#10 The B-52’s
pass

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

Greg, ma brobrick, that connection down there in Guatemala is more effed up than ever. read your lines though

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

#1 Michael Jackson
#8 Def Leppard
#5 Paul Simon
Pass
#3 Kraftwerk
#11 The Commodores
#7 Paul McCartney/Wings
#2 The Police

Re: UMT2:70's Region, Bracket #4

RESULTS:
Michael Jackson 87.5% / Richard And LInda Thompson 12.5%
Def Leppard 60% / George Harrison 40%
Paul Simon 71.9% / Squeeze 28.1%
Rush 67.9% / Bill Withers 32.1%
Kraftwerk 51.7% / The Gap Band 48.3%
Kiss 53.6% / The Commodores 46.4%
Paul McCartney/Wings 59.4% The B-52's 40.6%
The Police 96.9% / The Knack 3.1%