Put a Pin on the Map View my Forum Guestmap
Free Guestmaps by Bravenet.com

The Old Acclaimed Music Forum

Go to the NEW FORUM

Music, music, music...
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

Vote for your winners, results posted tomorrow...

#1 Prince vs. #16 The English Beat
#8 Alice Cooper vs. #9 Electric Light Orchestra
#5 Tom Waits vs. #12 Buzzcocks
#4 Billy Joel vs. #13 Pat Benetar
#3 Steely Dan vs. #14 Derek and the Dominoes
#6 The Human League vs. #11 The Ohio Players
#7 Cheap Trick vs. #10 Brian Eno
#2 John Lennon vs. #15 Heart

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

Prince
pass
Buzzcocks (tough draw)
pass
Steely Dan
The Human League
Brian Eno
pass

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

#1 Prince
#9 Electric Light Orchestra (just)
#5 Tom Waits
#4 Billy Joel (well...)
#3 Steely Dan!
#6 The Human League
#10 Brian Eno
#2 John Lennon

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

Prince
Alice Cooper
Tom Waits
Billy Joel
Steely Dan
The Human League
Brian Eno
John Lennon

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

#16 The English Beat
#9 Electric Light Orchestra
#12 Buzzcocks
#13 Pat Benetar
#14 Derek and the Dominoes
#11 The Ohio Players
#10 Brian Eno
#2 John Lennon

Thanks!

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

#1 Prince
#9 Electric Light Orchestra
#5 Tom Waits
#13 Pat Benatar
Pass
#6 Human League
#10 Brian Eno
#2 John Lennon

These are some cruel matchups.

In some cases, I really like both acts: Prince/Beat, Waits/Buzzcocks, Cheap Trick/Eno.

In others, I dislike or am at least meh on both: Joel/Benatar, Dan/Derek, Lennon/Heart. Frankly, I would have taken the Ohio Players over almost all of those guys.

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

#1 PRINCE
#9 ELO
#12 Buzzcocks (Hate Tom Waits!!!)
#4 Billy
#3 Steely Dan
#6 Human League
#7 Cheap Trick
#15 Heart (Somebody has to vote for them, I kinda like Barracuda & Magic Man!!!)

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

Prince
ELO
Tom Waits (tough call)
pass
Steely Dan
Human League
Brian Eno (I think he's the best overall artist of the 70s...he better at least win this matchup)
John Lennon

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

Prince
Alice Cooper
Tom Waits
Billy Joel
Steely Dan
The Human League
Brian Eno
John Lennon

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

#16 The English Beat
#9 Electric Light Orchestra
#12 Buzzcocks
#4 Billy Joel
#3 Steely Dan
#6 The Human League
#7 Cheap Trick
#2 John Lennon

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

#1 Prince
#8 Alice Cooper (very close call)
#5 Tom Waits
#13 Pat Benatar
#3 Steely Dan
#11 The Ohio Players
#10 Brian Eno
#2 John Lennon

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

pass
#9 Electric Light Orchestra
#5 Tom Waits
#4 Billy Joel
tie
#11 The Ohio Players
#10 Brian Eno
#2 John Lennon

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

#1 Prince
pass (Should probably vote ELO just to cancel out exposure advantage)
#5 Tom Waits
#4 Billy Joel
#14 Derek and the Dominoes
#6 The Human League
#10 Brian Eno
#2 John Lennon

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

#1 Prince: 20 defeats #16 The English Beat: 13
#8 Alice Cooper: 12 defeats #9 Electric Light Orchestra: 8
#5 Tom Waits: 15 defeats #12 Buzzcocks: 13
#13 Pat Benetar: 13 defeats #4 Billy Joel: 7
#3 Steely Dan: 11 defeats #14 Derek and the Dominoes: 10
#6 The Human League: 17 defeats #11 The Ohio Players: 12
#10 Brian Eno: 15 defeats #7 Cheap Trick: 10
#15 Heart: 13 defeats #2 John Lennon: 0

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

#1 Prince
#8 Alice Cooper
#5 Tom Waits
#4 Billy Joel
#3 Steely Dan
#6 The Human League
#10 Brian Eno
#15 Heart

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

Prince
ELO
Tom Waits
Pat Benetar
Steely Dan
The Human League
Cheap Trick
Heart

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

#1 Prince
#9 Electric Light Orchestra
#12 Buzzcocks
#4 Billy Joel
#3 Steely Dan
#6 The Human League
#7 Cheap Trick
#2 John Lennon

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

Prince
Cooper (close, but not really in a good way)
pass
Billy
D&D (Damn close, in the good way)
pass
Cheap Trick
Heart (My hating on Lennon's overyoko solo career continues)

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

#1 Prince
#9 Electric Light Orchestra
#12 Buzzcocks
#4 Billy Joel
#3 Steely Dan
#6 The Human League
#10 Brian Eno
#2 John Lennon

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

Prince
Alice Cooper
Buzzcocks
Billy Joel
Steely Dan
Human League
Cheap Trick
John Lennon

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

Jackson

Brian Eno (I think he's the best overall artist of the 70s...he better at least win this matchup)


Looks like it could be tough for Eno.

I am not particularly familiar with Eno's solo efforts. He did not have a big following when I was at SUNY at Stony Brook (73-77)

My guess is that many of Eno's songs are not the most accessible. Perhaps you could recommend a few songs that are reasonably accessible and some others that are the most likely to impress after many listenings.

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

#1 Prince
#9 Electric Light Orchestra
#5 Tom Waits
#13 Pat Benetar
#3 Steely Dan
#6 The Human League
#10 Brian Eno
Pass

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

#9 Electric Light Orchestra
#5 Tom Waits
#4 Billy Joel
#14 Derek and the Dominoes
#10 Brian Eno
#2 John Lennon

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

Henry
Jackson

Brian Eno (I think he's the best overall artist of the 70s...he better at least win this matchup)


Looks like it could be tough for Eno.

I am not particularly familiar with Eno's solo efforts. He did not have a big following when I was at SUNY at Stony Brook (73-77)

My guess is that many of Eno's songs are not the most accessible. Perhaps you could recommend a few songs that are reasonably accessible and some others that are the most likely to impress after many listenings.


Eno is more of an albums artist, I think.

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

RESULTS:

Prince 93.5% / English Beat 6.5%
ELO 58.1% / Alice Cooper 41.9%
Tom Waits 58.1% / Buzzcocks 41.9%
Billy Joel 71% / Pat Benetar 29%
Steely Dan 80.6% / Derek & The Dominoes 19.4%
The Human League 73.3% / The Ohio Players 26.7%
Cheap Trick 51.5% / Brian Eno 48.5%
John Lennon 66.7% / Heart 33.3%

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

Really sad to see Eno leave. I agree that he is an album artist, but there are a few songs that really stand out to me, so here's for you Henry...

By This River - from "Before and After Science"
Golden Hours - from "Another Green World"
Fat Lady of Limbourg - from "Taking Tiger Mountain (By Strategy)"
Deep Blue Day - from "Apollo (Atmospheres and Soundtracks)"
An Ending (Ascent) - from "Apollo (Atmospheres and Soundtracks)"
Regiment - from "My Life in the Bush of Ghosts" with David Byrne

There are many ways to approach and enjoy Eno, but these are my recommendations. I wouldn't start with "Here Come the Warm Jets", it's not my cup of tea.

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

I would add Third Uncle and St Elmo's Fire, though I discovered both through (great) covers.

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

I'm glad you liked it, Nassim.

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

John Parr
I'm glad you liked it, Nassim.

Re: UMT2: 70's Region, Bracket #1

#1 Prince
#8 Alice Cooper
#12 Buzzcocks
#4 Billy Joel
#14 Derek and the Dominoes
#6 The Human League
#10 Brian Eno
#2 John Lennon