Put a Pin on the Map View my Forum Guestmap
Free Guestmaps by Bravenet.com

The Old Acclaimed Music Forum

Go to the NEW FORUM

Music, music, music...
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

Welcome back to the 2nd installment of The Ultimate Music Tournament. Vote for your favorite, winners to be announced tomorrow:

#1 The Beatles vs. #16 Herbie Hancock
#8 Fats Domino vs. #9 Bob Seger
#5 The Band vs. #12 The Spinners
#4 Sam Cooke vs. #13 Grand Funk Railroad
#3 Aretha Franklin vs. #14 Dean Martin
#6 Muddy Waters vs. #11 The Yardbirds
#7 Bee Gees vs. #10 Neil Diamond
#2 Johnny Cash vs. #15 Martha and the Vandellas

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

Winners:
#1 The Beatles
#8 Fats Domino
#5 The Band
#4 Sam Cooke
#3 Aretha Franklin
#11 The Yardbirds
#7 Bee Gees
#2 Johnny Cash

Thanks!

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

Easy ones, with Spinners being the only upset.

#1 The Beatles
#8 Fats Domino
#12 The Spinners
#4 Sam Cooke
#3 Aretha Franklin
#6 Muddy Waters
#7 Bee Gees
#2 Johnny Cash

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

#1 The Beatles
#8 Fats Domino
#5 The Band
#4 Sam Cooke
#3 Aretha Franklin
#6 Muddy Waters
#7 Bee Gees
#2 Johnny Cash

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

#1 The Beatles
#8 Fats Domino
#12 The Spinners
#4 Sam Cooke
#3 Aretha Franklin
#6 Muddy Waters
#10 Neil Diamond
#15 Martha and the Vandellas

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

#16 Herbie Hancock
#8 Fats Domino
#5 The Band
#4 Sam Cooke
#3 Aretha Franklin
#6 Muddy Waters
#10 Neil Diamond
#2 Johnny Cash

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

#16 Herbie Hancock
#8 Fats Domino
#5 The Band (by the way The Spinners were '70s)
#4 Sam Cooke
#3 Aretha Franklin
#6 Muddy Waters
#7 Bee Gees
#2 Johnny Cash

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

#1 The Beatles
#9 Bob Seger
#5 The Band
#4 Sam Cooke
#3 Aretha Franklin
#6 Muddy Waters
#10 Neil Diamond - Am I the only one who thinks the Bee Gees were watered down, uninspired disco? Should I acquaint myself with their earlier work? Still, I like Diamond and he deserves my vote regardless of my feelings for the Brothers Gibb.
#2 Johnny Cash

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

sonofsamiam
#16 Herbie Hancock
#8 Fats Domino
#5 The Band (by the way The Spinners were '70s)
#4 Sam Cooke
#3 Aretha Franklin
#6 Muddy Waters
#7 Bee Gees
#2 Johnny Cash



These are based loosely off of each artists debut single or album. Artists like The Spinners, Zeppelin, Bowie, Chicago etc made there mark in the 70's but debuted in the 60's. That is why you will find them here.

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

1. The Beatles
8. Fats Domino
5. The Band
4. Sam Cooke
3. Aretha Franklin
6. Muddy Waters
7. Bee Gees
2. Johnny Cash

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

The Beatles
pass
The Band
Sam Cooke
Aretha Franklin
pass
Bee Gees
Johnny Cash

I like the format more than the previous one. Doing it decade-by-decade should level the playing field a lot more for newer artists.

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

Slick

These are based loosely off of each artists debut single or album. Artists like The Spinners, Zeppelin, Bowie, Chicago etc made there mark in the 70's but debuted in the 60's. That is why you will find them here.


hmmmmmm not sure how I feel about this. That means a band like Nirvana who is really intrinsically associated with the 90's will be placed in the 80's category simply because of a long forgotten 1989 debut.

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

#1 The Beatles
#9 Bob Seger
#5 The Band
#4 Sam Cooke
#3 Aretha Franklin
#11 The Yardbirds
#7 Bee Gees
#2 Johnny Cash

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

#16 Herbie Hancock
#9 Bob Seger
#12 The Spinners
#4 Sam Cooke
#3 Aretha Franklin
#6 Muddy Waters
#7 Bee Gees
#15 Martha and the Vandellas

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

Chalk all the way.

#1 The Beatles (tough break for Herbie, a very inventive jazz artist)
#8 Fats Domino (This may be an 8/9 matchup but it’s the easiest one today.)
#5 The Band
#4 Sam Cooke
#3 Aretha Franklin (wow, Moonbeam must really hate Dean Martin)
#6 Muddy Waters (even Page, Beck and Clapton would agree with this one)
#7 Bee Gees (Gibb cheese and Neil cheese cancels out here)
#2 Johnny Cash (sorry to show Martha the door so quickly, but this is no contest)

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

schleuse

#3 Aretha Franklin (wow, Moonbeam must really hate Dean Martin)


Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

#1 The Beatles
#8 Seger
#12 The Spinners
#4 Sam Cooke
#3 Aretha Franklin
#6 Muddy Waters
#10 Neil Diamond
#2 Cash

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

#1 The Beatles
#8 Fats Domino
#5 The Band
#4 Sam Cooke
#3 Aretha Franklin
#6 Muddy Waters
#7 Bee Gees
#2 Johnny Cash

Voting down the line with the seeds today.

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

#1 The Beatles
#9 Bob Seger
#5 The Band
#4 Sam Cooke
#3 Aretha Franklin
#11 The Yardbirds
#7 Bee Gees
#2 Johnny Cash

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

Beatles
Seger
Band
Sam
Aretha
Yardbirds
bee gees
Cash

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

#1 The Beatles
#9 Bob Seger
#5 The Band
#4 Sam Cooke
#3 Aretha Franklin
#6 Muddy Waters
#7 Bee Gees
#2 Johnny Cash

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

WINNERS:

The Beatles 89.6% / Herbie Hancock 10.4%
Bob Seger 59.2% / Fats Domino 40.8%
The Band 64.3% / The Spinners 35.7%
Sam Cooke 79.3% / Grand Funk 20.7%
Aretha 89.6% / Dean Martin 10.4%
Muddy Waters 65.3% / The Yardbirds 34.7%
Bee Gees 55.1% / Neil Diamond 44.9%
Johnny Cash 93.1% / Martha & The Vandellas 6.9%

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

Slick
Bee Gees 55.1% / Neil Diamond 44.9%


How are those numbers possible? Do you really have that many voters on your other site, Slick?

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

Bee Gees won 16-13. There were 12 voters through e-mail / facebook and 17 on AM.

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

Schwah
Slick
Bee Gees 55.1% / Neil Diamond 44.9%


How are those numbers possible? Do you really have that many voters on your other site, Slick?
Schwah, I think you made the same mistake as I initially did, but after a while I realized it's not 50.1/49.9...

Re: UMT2: 50/60's Region, Bracket #1

You're right... that's exactly what I did Henrik.

Okay. I'm an idiot. Sorry Slick.