Put a Pin on the Map View my Forum Guestmap
Free Guestmaps by Bravenet.com

The Old Acclaimed Music Forum

Go to the NEW FORUM

Music, music, music...
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
Unacclaimed Week 20

Welcome to Week 20! We continue with bracket L2, featuring songs that have won one match and lost another match. The losers here are unfortunately out of the tournament!

Please listen to the songs before making your choice, and provide comments (however brief) to form the basis of your pick.

The deadline for Week 20 is 11:59 PM, March 12th AM time.

You can read the descriptions of why these songs were nominated in the rules thread.

Match L2.13:

M (Mathieu Chedid) - "Je dis aime"
Serge Gainsbourg - "Cannabis"

Match L2.14:

Wendy Rene - "After Laughter"
Lisa Germano - "Puppet"

Match L2.15:

The Bellrays - "Footprints on the Water"
Joanna Newsom - "Colleen"

Match L2.16:

Stereophonics - "Local Boy in the Photograph"
OK Go - "A Million Ways"

Re: Unacclaimed Week 20

Yeah, let's try this again. Deadline extended one week.

Re: Unacclaimed Week 20

Sorry about that MB, completely missed the post.

Match L2.13:
M (Mathieu Chedid) - "Je dis aime"
Serge Gainsbourg - "Cannabis"

Battle of the Frenchmen, and Serge destroys Mathieu.

Match L2.14:
Wendy Rene - "After Laughter"
Lisa Germano - "Puppet"

I'm starting to enjoy "After Laughter" a lot, and I already liked Puppet quite a bit, so this is definitely the strongest bracket of the week for me. I'm in a '60s mood though, so Rene wins.

Match L2.15:
The Bellrays - "Footprints on the Water"
Joanna Newsom - "Colleen"

I don't see the appeal in Newsom, so it's an easy choice.

Match L2.16:
Stereophonics - "Local Boy in the Photograph"
OK Go - "A Million Ways"

OK Go is more my cup of tea.

Re: Unacclaimed Week 20

Match L2.13:
M (Mathieu Chedid) - "Je dis aime"
Serge Gainsbourg - "Cannabis" WINNER
Again, like the vocal version best, but even instrumentally, Serge takes it.

Match L2.14:
Wendy Rene - "After Laughter"
Lisa Germano - "Puppet" WINNER
Probably my favorite discovery of the tournament.

Match L2.15:
The Bellrays - "Footprints on the Water"
Joanna Newsom - "Colleen" WINNER
I simply enjoy Newsom so much more.

Match L2.16:

Stereophonics - "Local Boy in the Photograph"
OK Go - "A Million Ways" WINNER
Not crazy about "Local Boy" and OK Go gives a solid effort here, even without video.

Re: Unacclaimed Week 20

Match L2.13:
M (Mathieu Chedid) - "Je dis aime"
Serge Gainsbourg - "Cannabis"
I always like GAinsbourg more than anybody.

Match L2.14:
Wendy Rene - "After Laughter"
Lisa Germano - "Puppet"
One of my favorites in this game.

Match L2.15:
The Bellrays - "Footprints on the Water"
Joanna Newsom - "Colleen"
Joanna boring me.

Match L2.16:
Stereophonics - "Local Boy in the Photograph"
OK Go - "A Million Ways"[/b]
Not easy to choose, I don't really like the two songs.

Moonbeam, do you have the results for the Week 19 ?

Re: Unacclaimed Week 20

Match L2.13:

M (Mathieu Chedid)- Je Dis Aime

As I said previously, I don't like this Gainsbourg song.

Match L2.14:

Wendy Rene - After Laughter

Great classic, basis of one the Wu greatest songs.

Match L2.15:

Joanna Newsom - Colleen

Might have became one of my favorite Joanna's songs while I find Bellrays completely overrated (in France at least, I don't have the feeling it is the case elsewhere given their lack of success in AM)

Match L2.16:

OK Go - A Million Ways

Fun song, that's enough here.

Re: Unacclaimed Week 20

Bellrays

I really like that Newsom song, but I nominated this one for a reason.

Stereophonics

I enjoy this song, whereas I think OK Go is kind of middlish without the videos.

Re: Unacclaimed Week 20

Serg Gainsbourg-This piece is groovy!

Lisa Germano-Gritty and Dark beats Sugary and Bright.

Bellrays-Great beat beats a song that was just too lowkey to win this time.

Sterophonics-Always will remain one of my favorites.

Re: Unacclaimed Week 20

Match L2.13 Winner - Serge Gainsbourg
A French battle! Gainsbourg's dirty funk wins easily.

Match 2.14 Winner - Wendy Rene
Two genres I like head to head. But "Puppet" just didn't grab me, "After Laguhter" has a little more.

Match 2.15 Winner - The Bellrays
Really tough call. I really like both and only Cannabis compares to the two this week. The Bellrays groove grabbed me a little more.

Match 2.16 Winner - Stereophonics
A finely delivered, if somewhat staid, rock song. Same could be said for OK Go's song, but the Stereophonics bumber grabs me more

Re: Unacclaimed Week 20

Match L2.13:

M (Mathieu Chedid) - "Je dis aime": In the toughest match of the week, this just barely loses. I like its quirky delivery.
Serge Gainsbourg - "Cannabis": Hearing the version with vocals warmed me up to this. With all of the respect he gets here, maybe it's time I checked out Serge's music.

Match L2.14:

Wendy Rene - "After Laughter": This just seems like average soul to me. Not bad at all, but not particularly good, either.
Lisa Germano - "Puppet": Somehow lost amidst the 90s alterna-chick wave, this is a nice discovery.

Match L2.15:

The Bellrays - "Footprints on the Water": In another close, close match, this one just squeaks by.
Joanna Newsom - "Colleen": I hate to vote against her again, but I've got some obstacle with Joanna Newsom that hasn't been overcome, despite her obvious talent.

Match L2.16:

Stereophonics - "Local Boy in the Photograph": No thank you.
OK Go - "A Million Ways": I'm not big on OK Go, but this is as good as they get for me.

Re: Unacclaimed Week 20

There is a tie once again! Next vote wins it.

Re: Unacclaimed Week 20

I saw that it was too late, but i saw the tie now, i needed to vote!

M (Mathieu Chedid) - "Je dis aime"
Serge Gainsbourg - "Cannabis"

French war! Serge all the way!

Match L2.14:

Wendy Rene - "After Laughter"
Lisa Germano - "Puppet"

Puppet is still a strong song and the video only enhances it, it grew to become one of my favorites in the whole competition.

Match L2.15:

The Bellrays - "Footprints on the Water"
Joanna Newsom - "Colleen"

Joanna is queen, she might lose it, but she's the best singer/songwriter on the game since 2004!

Match L2.16:

Stereophonics - "Local Boy in the Photograph"
OK Go - "A Million Ways"

OK Go was fun disposable indie pop, i enjoyed it more than Stereophonics's.

Re: Unacclaimed Week 20

There is still a tie because BillAdama only voted for 2 songs. In that case, though, I'll eliminate my own vote.

Re: Unacclaimed Week 20

Winners for Week 20:

M (Mathieu Chedid) - "Je dis aime": 1
Serge Gainsbourg - "Cannabis": 7

Wendy Rene - "After Laughter": 4
Lisa Germano - "Puppet": 3

The Bellrays - "Footprints on the Water": 6
Joanna Newsom - "Colleen": 3

Stereophonics - "Local Boy in the Photograph": 4
OK Go - "A Million Ways": 5

As nobody broke the tie in Match L2.15, I eliminated my own vote.