No, this one was declared ineligible from the moment it first appeared in 2007. It's purely an industry-created and market-driven list. Fun to look at, but no critical value whatsoever. (#95. That's all I'm sayin'.)

#95, Harold- plenty of commercial, non-critical-hit albums on here. :)

It looked awfully suspect but I came accross and thought I'd pass it on just in case.