Put a Pin on the Map View my Forum Guestmap
Free Guestmaps by Bravenet.com

The Old Acclaimed Music Forum

Go to the NEW FORUM

Music, music, music...
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
View Entire Thread
Re: New list - "Le Mag Indie Rock" - 100 artistes, 100 albums : le bouquet final.

Sorry, at the second place, we found all this list and all the list in the first post must be push (the Smiths take the 12th place for exemple for a total of 109 albums):

2. Aphex Twin - Richard D. James Album
2. Björk - Post (Islande - 1995)
2. Can - Tago Mago (Allemagne - 1971)
2. Cat Power - Moon Pix (US - 1998)
2. Dominique A - Remué (France - 1999)
2. Hood - Cold House (UK - 2001)
2. Jack - The End Of The Way It’s Always Been (UK - 2002)
2. Madrugada - The Nightly Disease (Norvège - 2001)
2. Oxbow - The Narcotic Story (US - 2007)
2. The Six Parts Seven - Casually Smashed To Pieces (US - 2007)

Re: New list - "Le Mag Indie Rock" - 100 artistes, 100 albums : le bouquet final.

I don't get this - are the 10 albums in the second post listed as being "tied for #2" or "runners-up" for #1 or what? How exactly are the albums from THE QUEEN IS DEAD onward ranked?

Re: New list - "Le Mag Indie Rock" - 100 artistes, 100 albums : le bouquet final.

Sorry I speak english very bad, it's difficult to explain clearly.
The only number one is : 1. Radiohead - OK computer
Ten number two (all the album of my second post)
All the other albums are bring forward ten place: to number 12. The Smiths at number 109. XTC.

I hope you understand

Re: New list - "Le Mag Indie Rock" - 100 artistes, 100 albums : le bouquet final.

Thanks for clarifying. I still don't quite get the purpose of that, but it makes sense now.

Re: New list - "Le Mag Indie Rock" - 100 artistes, 100 albums : le bouquet final.

Romaint, thanks for this list. However, I don't include readers' lists and I found this page, where - although I can't speak French - it looks like half of the 50 of the albums you posted were readers' picks and the remaining albums were complementing albums by the staff of the site.

Hence, the list will not be included at AM. OK?

Re: New list - "Le Mag Indie Rock" - 100 artistes, 100 albums : le bouquet final.

It's exactly that ! Half of the list is reader's choice and half is "Le MAg"'s choice.
No problem to don't include this, I understand the huge work for doing what you do. Thanks for this !

I put the list because I found it interesting with some album rarelly citated.

Re: New list - "Le Mag Indie Rock" - 100 artistes, 100 albums : le bouquet final.

Some great stuff on this list. I don't understand their choice of Sonic Youth album though. Goo is pretty so-so.